TERRE HAUTE — The legal battle for control of the Terre Haute mayor’s office will be contested in a face-to-face showdown in front of the Indiana Court of Appeals next month.
The appeals court has agreed to hear oral arguments in the case pitting Mayor Duke Bennett against former Mayor Kevin Burke. The arguments are scheduled for July 8 in Indianapolis.
Lawyers for Burke requested the opportunity to argue their case in front of a three-judge appeals court panel earlier this year. Lawyers for Bennett did not object to the request and have asked that recordings of the arguments be made available online through the Indiana Court of Appeals Web site.
“We think [the oral arguments and Webcast are] a good opportunity for the people in Terre Haute to understand more concretely what the issues are,” said Bryan Babb of the Indianapolis law firm of Bose, McKinney and Evans.
Babb will make Bennett’s case to the court.
The appeals court only agrees to “hear oral arguments in a small percentage of cases and so we are glad that they are willing to hear it in this particular case,” said Amanda Couture, an attorney with the DeLaney and DeLaney law firm of Indianapolis, which is representing Burke.
Burke’s case will be argued in front of the three-judge appeals panel by Ed DeLaney.
Each side will have 30 minutes to make its case.
No new evidence is presented in an appeals case and no new witnesses are called. Judges typically ask questions during oral arguments and “the point of the [oral] argument is really to have a discussion with the judges,” Couture said.
When the court agrees to hear oral arguments it often means the judges want clarification on some matters, Babb said. And while he expects both sides to repeat the arguments they have made in their legal briefs, questions from the judges will determine what is discussed, he added. “We’ll go wherever the judges take us,” Babb said.
Bennett won the Terre Haute mayor’s race last November by 110 votes out of about 12,000 cast. Burke later challenged Bennett’s eligibility to take office based on the Hatch Act, a law that limits the political activity of federal employees and employees of some not-for-profit organizations that receive federal money.
Vigo County Circuit Court Judge David Bolk ruled against Burke in December, allowing Bennett to take office. However, Bolk also ruled that Bennett had been subject to the Hatch Act when he ran for office.
Burke later appealed Bolk’s decision to allow Bennett to take office. Bennett then appealed Bolk’s ruling that Bennett had been subject to the Hatch Act when he ran for mayor. This means the appeals court is hearing two appeals from one ruling.
This is “not just a dispute between two individuals. It’s a dispute that will affect an entire city,” Couture said. Burke is arguing that state law requires that Bennett be removed from office and Burke, as the person receiving the second-most votes, should be returned to power in City Hall.
One of the three judges who will hear the case is new to the Indiana Court of Appeals. Gov. Mitch Daniels named Judge Elaine Brown to the appeals bench last month. The other judges assigned to the case, Edward W. Najam Jr. and Carr L. Darden, were appointed by former Gov. Evan Bayh in the 1990s.
The attorneys for both sides have experience making oral arguments. DeLaney has argued before the appeals court several times and is arguing a case before the Indiana Supreme Court next Monday, Couture said. Babb has presented two oral arguments this month alone, he said.
“It’s the best thing I do as a lawyer,” Babb said. “It’s a great privilege to talk in front of that court.”
Arthur Foulkes can be reached at (812) 231-4232 or arthur.foulkes@tribstar.com.
ZZZ Delete Legacy
Court agrees to hear oral arguments in Burke, Bennett case
- ZZZ Delete Legacy
-
-
Florence Elizabeth 'Flo' Hogue
Florence Elizabeth “Flo” Hogue, 87, of Terre Haute, passed away Saturday, June 26, 2010, in Union Hospital. Florence worked many years for Albert Pick Motel before retirement. She was born Aug. 4, 1922, in Red Oak, Iowa, to Samuel Valentine and Nancy Jane (Allendar) Valentine.
-
Kenneth E. Levin
Kenneth E. Levin, formerly of Terre Haute, passed away Saturday, June 26, 2010, in The Villages, Fla. Kenneth was born May 3, 1924, to A.N. Levin and Jenny (Brown) Levin, in Terre Haute.
-
Ruth Ann Dugger Morris
Ruth Ann Dugger Morris, 80, of Terre Haute, died Saturday, June 26, 2010, at Terre Haute Regional Hospital. Ruth Ann was born Aug. 26, 1929, in Vigo County, to Georgia Dugger Dickey and Roy Dugger.
-
Audrey Olah
Audrey Olah, 90, of Terre Haute, died June 22, 2010, at Southwood Health & Rehabilitation Center. Born at home on Oct. 14, 1919, in rural Clay County, she endured the Great Depression as a farmer’s daughter in Lewis, worked at Owens- Illinois Glass Company during World War II, and was an initial hire of Dr. Morey’s Glas-Col Apparatus Co.
-
Harrison Cabell Shade
Harrison Cabell Shade, 81, of Terre Haute, died Thursday, June 24, 2010, at Terre Haute Regional Hospital. Born April 20, 1929, in Terre Haute, to Henry Shade and Sheppelle Morton Shade.
-
Norma Mae McAtee
LINTON — Nora Mae McAtee, 91, of Linton, passed away Monday, June 28, 2010, at Glenburn Home. She was born in Knox County, on May 25, 1919, to Albert Clarence and Anna Mary (Strahle) Miller.
-
Ronald Dale Rozina
CLINTON — Ronald Dale Rozina, 53, of Clinton, passed away Sunday, June 27, 2010, at Methodist Hospital in Indianapolis. He was born Sept. 21, 1956, in Clinton, the son of John “Shine” Rozina and Frieda Hinkle Rozina.
-
Jerry Rex McDonald
MARTINSVILLE, Ind. — Jerry Rex McDonald, 77, of Martinsville, passed from this life on Saturday, June 26, 2010, at 2:09 p.m., at Community Hospital South in Indianapolis. He was born in Riley, on Feb. 15, 1933, to the late Harry E. McDonald and Lucille (Reed) Barnett.
-
Madelyne Skipo
Madelyne Skipo, 86, of Terre Haute, went home to be with the Lord early Saturday evening, June 26, 2010, at Davis Gardens Health Center. She was born Sept. 29, 1923, in Hymera, to Tracey and Hayley Mahan.
-
William D. Farris
BRAZIL — William D. Farris, 76, of Brazil, died Sunday, June 27, 2010, at the Exceptional Living Center. He was born May 29, 1934, in Brazil, the son of Stanley and Vada (Flockhart) Farris.
- Death Notice: June 29, 2010
-
William Freeman
BRAZIL — William Freeman, 75, of Brazil, passed away at St. Vincent Clay Hospital’s emergency room, on June 28, 2010, from an apparent heart attack. He was born in Clay City, on Aug. 15, 1934, the son of Russell and Lora (Greenwell) Freeman.
-
Jewell M. Ennen
Jewell M. Ennen, 80, of Terre Haute, died at 4:25 a.m. Thursday, June 24, 2010. She was born in Phoenix, on March 20, 1930, to Merlin and Odessa (Caldwell) Arthur.
-
Valerio Chironna
Lifelong Staten Islander Valerio (Val) Chironna, 86, of Eltingville, the owner of a fuel oil company, died Saturday, June 12, 2010, in Staten Island University Hospital, Ocean Breeze, N.Y.
- Death Notices: June 25, 2010
-
Ruth P. Klingler Lietchy
Ruth P. Klingler Liechty, 85, of Terre Haute, died at 8:53 a.m. Wednesday, June 23, 2010, in Davis Gardens Health Center. She was born in Clay County, on June 5, 1925, to Uly Klingler and Mary Rentschler Klingler.
-
Pauline Arnold Mobley
Pauline Arnold Mobley, 89, passed from this Earth on Wednesday, June 23, 2010, at Meadows Manor North Nursing Home, where she resided for six years. Pauline was born Oct. 21, 1920, to John Ernst Arnold and Ora Alta Wilson.
-
Mary Margaret Curry
Mary Margaret Curry, 70, of Terre Haute, passed away at 8:30 p.m. on Sunday, June 20, 2010, in Terre Haute Regional Hospital. She was born in Matheson Ontario, Canada, on July 10, 1939, to William Melville Moffat and Mary Janet Mulligan Moffat.
-
Beulah F. Funk
Beulah F. Funk, 81, of Terre Haute, passed away Sunday afternoon, June 20, 2010, at the ELC of Brazil. She was born Sept. 30, 1928, in Vincennes, to John Huebner and Agnes Bowman Huebner.
-
Robert T. Scott
SULLIVAN — Robert T. Scott, 91, of Sullivan, and formerly of Farmersburg, died June 21, 2010, in Sullivan County Community Hospital. He was born Feb. 7, 1919, to Thomas and Edith (Lewis) Scott.
-
Maxine LaVerna Noble
Maxine LaVerna Noble, 81, of Terre Haute, passed away at 2:30 a.m. Sunday, June 20, 2010, at Southwood Health and Rehabilitation Center. She was born in Terre Haute, on June 20, 1929, to Albert Lowe and Stella Rice Lowe.
-
Charles 'Pune' William Ellinger Jr.
Charles “Pune” William Ellinger Jr., 58, of Terre Haute, passed away on June 19, 2010, at 9:25 p.m., at Union Hospital. He was born June 25, 1951. in Terre Haute, to Charles W. Ellinger and Betty L. Hooker Ellinger.
- Death Notices: June 22, 2010
-
Saralu Thomas
DANA — Saralu Thomas, 86, of Dana, died at 5 a.m. Monday, June 21, 2010, at the Waters Nursing Home of Clinton. She was the retired owner/operator of Thomas Corner Store, in Dana, for 16 years. She was born Sept. 5, 1923, in Dana, to the late Dwight Thompson and Millie Thomson Thompson.
-
June Evelyn Trout Mormans
STAUNTON — June Evelyn Trout Mormans passed away in her home on Saturday, June 19, 2010. She was born July 1, 1928, to Clarence and Winifred (Gilliatt) Trout, and was a life-long resident of Staunton.
-
Marjorie E. Muir Allbright Wiot
Marjorie E. Muir Allbright Wiot, 85, of Terre Haute, formerly of Parke County, passed away at 1:20 a.m. Sunday, June 20, 2010, at Davis Gardens Health Center, in Terre Haute, from natural causes. Born June 10, 1925, in Parke County, she was the daughter of Carl J. Muir and Alice Wimmer Muir.
-
Gregory D. Barnett
BRAZIL — Gregory D. Barnett, 58, died Sunday, June 20, 2010, at St. Vincent Clay Hospital. He was born Feb. 27, 1952, in Kokomo, to Donald A. and Johanna Keegan Barnett.
-
Tyler E. Jackson
Tyler E. Jackson, 21, of Terre Haute, passed away Tuesday morning, June 15, 2010. He was employed with Walmart in Terre Haute. He was born Nov. 14, 1988, in Jasper.
- Death Notices: June 18, 2010
-
Franklin John Followell
Franklin John Followell, 74, of Terre Haute, died in Terre Haute Regional Hospital Tuesday, June 15, 2010, at 8:50 p.m. He was born on March 19, 1936, in Sullivan County, to William Homer Followell and Florence (Martin) Followell.
- More ZZZ Delete Legacy Headlines
-
Pop Music Superstar Whitney Houston Dies at 48
Raw Video: Whitney Houston's Last Performance
Police: Houston Found Dead in Her Hotel Room
Fans 'Speechless' Over Houston's Death
Reaction to Houston's Death at Clive Davis Party
Recording Superstar Whitney Houston Dead at 48
Paul Suffers Narrow Loss to Romney in Maine
Palin Brings Anti-Washington Message to CPAC
Whitney Houston's Church Mourns Her Passing
Maine GOP Chairman Says Romney Wins Caucuses
Raw Video: Deadly Blasts in Syria
Obama Scraps Birth Control Mandate
Snow Strands Italian Towns
Winter Slamming North Asia, Parts of Europe
Latest Jason Wu Collection Shows Chinese Roots
US Airmen's Killer Sentenced to Life in Germany
Raw Video: Rough Seas Stop Oil Removal
ShowBiz Minute: Madonna, Beresford-Redman, Pawsc
The Pits: Israelis Spit Olives for Glory
Video of M.I.A's Obscene Halftime Gesture
2012 Grammys: LL Cool J
Exclusive Video - Whitney's Bodybag
FUEL TV: Punk Payback Gym tips
Raw Video: Child Rescued After Kosovo Avalanche
Whitney's Final Days - EXCLUSIVE
Raw Video: Aurora Borealis As Seen From Space
First glimpse of Blue Ivy Carter
Lusetich: AT&T Rd. 3 recap
Peek inside Barbie's closet
Romney Tops Santorum in CPAC Straw Poll
Madonna's Daughter Shaves Head
Angry Dad Shoots Teens Laptop
Absolute Lin-sanity
5 Killed in Wrong-way Crash on I-10 in La.
Test on Comforter in Powell Unit Shows Blood
Hero Driver Saves Kids From Burning Bus
Funeral to be held for Powell boys
Sandusky on having to stay inside and people turning on him
Uzbek Man Pleads Guilty in Plot to Kill Obama
Woolly Mammoth Caught on Camera?
