I have gotten my share of report cards. In my scholastic career, I received approximately 80 statistical measurements of my efforts in assimilation of the materials that were reviewed in class and in textbooks. It also reflected my efforts on various projects such as research papers and other homework assigned over the years. I was a pretty good student, not a great one, and my grades reflected my efforts. I was always told that if I did my best, my grades would reflect the effort, and I would be rewarded.
I guess times have changed.
While reading the Tribune-Star on Thursday, I saw that the grades were out from the Indiana Department of Education for each of the schools. In Vigo County, 23 of 27 schools were in the top three categories: A, B or C. There were two schools that received D’s, and two — including one school, Chauncey Rose Middle School, that is now closed — that got F’s. The other F was given to West Vigo Elementary School.
I was then drawn to a story written by the CNHI statehouse reporter, Maureen Hayden, that accompanied our local report. She wrote about a meeting of the state Board of Education on Wednesday, and reported comments made by the state Superintendent of Public Instruction, Tony Bennett. As he addressed the system by which the grades were determined, Bennett indicated that the new system has “some complexity” that will make it difficult for parents, students, teachers and others to understand how the grades are determined. He went on to state that we should compare the grades doled out to the safety rating given to cars. “You understand the rating, but not everything that goes into it,” Bennett said.
In full disclosure, I have two boys in the Vigo County school system; one attends Honey Creek Middle School and the other is a student at Terre Haute South Vigo High School. They both are getting a good education and are doing well, based on the grading system in place — which is just like it was when I went to school and is one that I understand. At our house, we believe that educating our children is a collaborative effort among my wife and me and the teachers at the schools. The grading system has been explained to the children and we all understand how it works. We believe it to be a realistic measure of their efforts and the testing they are given. I’m certain that understanding the grading system helps in determining action plans to improve the grades with increased effort on the part of all involved. The kids understand why they were given the grade and what they did both correctly and incorrectly to receive the earned grade. It’s not a mystery.
That’s what really perplexed me when I read about the grades for the schools. First, by Bennett’s admission, the system is difficult for many of those involved in the educational process — parents, teachers and administrators — to understand. Second, since I don’t make cars, I don’t understand the comparison to the safety ratings of automobiles. I sincerely hope that carmakers understand the rating system; I have been under the impression that they would know what they needed to do to improve safety. Otherwise, how do the automakers make a safer vehicle? I trust that the automakers and the ratings organization routinely communicate to improve the safety. And if the safety improved on a car, the safety rating would be better as a result of that improvement. If the teachers, parents and administrators don’t understand how the schools’ grades are determined, how does improvement take place?
West Vigo Elementary was penalized for low growth and did not achieve comparable growth to peers in the state. In 2010, that school scored the equivalent of an A, but in two years plummeted to an F from “exemplary.” The improvements were not at the same pace as that of other kids in the state, so not only did the grade slip, but went from best to worst. Huh?
There needs to be a system by which the effort of those teachers, administrators, parents and students is measured fairly. Not every student learns the same way or at the same rate. In the elementary school in West Terre Haute, the student body reflects an 80 percent poverty rate and 30 percent of the students are special needs. There are some great teachers there, and throughout the school system, who are working hard every day to improve the lives of those kids. It will take some of the best teachers to overcome those obstacles. But how long will good teachers stay in a school that is unfairly graded? Will they continue to be branded as F for very long before they just give up and transfer to the schools where the challenges are fewer but the grades will be better and seemingly more reflective of their efforts?
To Principal Peggy Pfrank and the teachers at the school and throughout Vigo County, thank you for your dedication and hard work. The grading system is not a true measurement of your effort, commitment and time investment in helping to improve the lives of our kids.
I still choose to believe what many of my teachers and my parents taught me when I was in school: If I do my best, I will be rewarded. It was true then, and it should be true now.
B.J. Riley is the publisher of the Tribune-Star. He can be reach at bjriley@tribstar.com and 812-231-4297.
News Columns
B.J. RILEY: Indiana school grading system should be made clear to everyone
- News Columns
-
-
STATE OF THE STATEHOUSE: Sentencing law could benefit juveniles
Monica Foster is a longtime public defender who’s been pushing uphill in the legal system for a long time. So, when she says the General Assembly is making progress protecting the rights of the disenfranchised, it’s worth stopping to listen to her.
-
MIKE LUNSFORD: We’ve created a honey of a problem
The Dutch clover is making its appearance in my yard this week. A cooler-than-usual spring has slowed its arrival by a few days, but it is here for now, bringing the honeybees and bumblebees with it.
-
MARK BENNETT: Time for surf, sand and a good book
I can read a book on the beach. Until I start sweating. Then it feels like exercise, minus the fitness perks. My brain shifts into neutral as the waves roll in, blissfully washing away footprints in the sand and my inclination to think. Better put, I enjoy starting a book on the beach, and finishing it later, elsewhere.
-
STATE OF THE STATEHOUSE: Requiring photo IDs for food-stamp users has already been tried
Voters in Indiana are required to show their photo IDs before they can cast their ballots. Should food stamp recipients in Indiana have to do the same when they go to the grocery store?
-
MIKE LUNSFORD: Remembering Mom a day after Mother’s Day
I don’t think there has been a day in the last eight years that I haven’t thought of my mom. Being all grown up with wrinkles to call my own doesn’t make me miss my parents any less.
-
MARK BENNETT: After running for 28 hours straight, what’s another 5 miles?
Some phrases can only be uttered by a few people, or none at all.
-
MARK BENNETT: Glitches show limitations of high-stakes testing concept
The dog ate my homework. That age-old excuse — based on a shockingly unforeseen complication — rarely works for a kid who didn’t finish yesterday’s math assignment. Yet, in a role reversal, Indiana school children, along with their teachers and administrators, are left to accept an explanation for a disruption best described as the mother of all ironies.
-
MARK BENNETT: One step at a time to save lives
Joan Brown.
Remember that name. -
MARK BENNETT: Sometimes, the mere posing of questions is significant
The era seems quaint now, almost like a fable. When people left their house doors unlocked. When the sight of a police officer in a school meant it was Career Day.
-
MIKE LUNSFORD: ‘Dowsers’ provide hope more than science
My grandfather was a man of God. Many times I saw him, his right hand held high in the air at his Wednesday night “prayer meeting,” praising the Lord before weeping at the altar on his knees. And yet, he was a “dowser,” a “diviner,” a “witcher” who, as a favor, would grab a forked sassafras stick and find water for some poor unfortunate whose well had gone dry.
-
MARK BENNETT: New reality steers Nashville singer to Crossroads for Historical Society concert
People pass through the Crossroads of America for lots of reasons.
Business trips. College campus events. Federal prison sentences. Visits with relatives. Gas pitstops.
Or maybe a career change and a twist of fate.
Ty Brown makes his first stop in downtown Terre Haute as the headliner of a multi-band Sweet Sensations Country Jam concert May 4 in the Ohio Building — a fundraiser for the Vigo County Historical Society. -
HAYDEN: 9-year-old lobbyist weighs in on school safety
Senate Bill 1 shot to the forefront last week, after it was amended by the House education committee with a provision that mandates every public school in Indiana would be required to have someone on staff armed with a loaded gun during school hours.
-
HAYDEN: Republican shift proving to be real
When a federal judge struck down key provisions of the state’s immigration law last week, it seemed anticlimactic.
-
LUNSFORD: A different kind of resurrection story, no foolin’
If you’ve had pets in your family long enough, it’s likely that you’ll see a miracle or two — a dog that couldn’t possibly have lived, but did; a cat that grew to 20 pounds after being born the runt of the litter; a goldfish that had been belly-up too many times to believe it could have survived another day.
-
STATE OF THE STATEHOUSE: Americans of Hispanic heritage becoming active in Republican party
When Republicans in the Indiana General Assembly decided earlier this year to put off a vote on locking the state’s same-sex marriage ban into the state constitution, it sent a signal that GOP leaders were evolving on the issue of marriage equality.
-
MARK BENNETT: Terre Haute barber ‘sharpens up’ customers for 50 years
People streamed through this section of downtown Terre Haute in those days.
“You could hardly walk by here,” John Hochhalter said, pointing toward the sidewalk outside the window.
The bustle has faded since the early 1960s. Hochhalter remains. He’s still barbering in the same shop he and late business partner Kenny Thomas opened a half-century ago this week. -
MIKE LUNSFORD: As of today, it’s unofficially spring
Despite the calendar telling us not to rush things, I think it is all right to go ahead and say spring is here. The Ides of March has passed, Easter is coming soon, and I have already been out in my yard with a rake, getting my boots muddy. It looks like spring to me.
-
Americans for Prosperity aim to browbeat GOP lawmakers
If you're outside the Indianapolis TV market, you may not have seen yet the Americans for Prosperity ad that demonizes the House Republicans for resisting Republican Gov. Mike Pence's tax cut plan.
-
MAUREEN HAYDEN: Pence may find himself in a mess if he gets what he wants
Here’s a story to consider: A Republican governor with ties to the tea party and possible presidential ambitions decides he wants to slash the state’s income tax rate, but meets with massive resistance from legislative leaders from his own party.
Sounds like the scenario playing out in the Indiana Statehouse, right? -
MARK BENNETT: Reflections of grid success stir with Brent Anderson’s passing
A few hundred miles away, and nearly 40 years gone by, a special game ball still occupies a fond place in Rudy Bohinc’s memories.
-
MIKE LUNSFORD: If handwriting is a window to my soul, I’m glad this is typewritten…
Somewhere in the mess I call my “archives,” I have most of my grade school report cards hidden away. I have kept them under wraps, because I want to be long gone when my children — or grandchildren — unearth them and discover that their self-righteous teacher of a dad was, in fact, a terrible student in his formative years.
-
MAUREEN HAYDEN: Are legislators gambling with the future of gaming?
Indiana lawmakers have been debating whether to give the state’s casinos more financial incentives to compete with the shiny new gambling palaces popping up in Ohio.
-
MARK BENNETT: Never truer: Knowledge vital to narrowing ‘skills gap’
The pillar at the gates of Faber College in the movie “Animal House” bore a wise motto, despite its tongue-in-cheek intent …
-
STATE OF THE STATEHOUSE: Pot decriminalization bill dead, but reduced-punishment aspect still alive
In the flurry of activity at the Statehouse in recent weeks, I missed reporting some sad news for stoners: The legislation to decriminalize marijuana is dead.
-
MARK BENNETT: Great-niece to re-enact Paul Dresser’s musical legacy in Terre Haute show
People can be forgotten. Their lives end, time passes and memories fade.
Often, the only keepers of their legacies are family and friends, who tell and retell their stories, generation to generation.
For Paul Dresser, his fame burned strong enough as a turn-of-the-century, million-seller songwriter to preserve bits of his public notoriety. -
MIKE LUNSFORD: The ‘lovely gift’ of a beech tree …
This is not the season that I usually write of trees, for besides a few pin oaks that hang on to the most stubborn of leaves, my woods stand bare and dormant and cold right now. My trees are patiently awaiting the green of spring that I feel, for some reason, is to arrive a little earlier this year than is usual.
-
STATE OF THE STATEHOUSE: What to do with that $2 billion sitting around
We Hoosiers like to think of ourselves as special, but when it comes to the current debate in the Indiana Statehouse over the budget, we’re a lot like other states: Grappling with some post-recession questions about how to balance spending and taxes.
-
MARK BENNETT: An Olympic takedown
Imagine an iconic image of American sports history erased.
-
STATE OF THE STATEHOUSE: Pence sticks to his ‘Roadmap’
As a U.S. congressman, Mike Pence made it perfectly clear how he felt about the need for a constitutional amendment to ban same-sex marriage.
-
MARK BENNETT: Indiana’s ‘skills gap’
A problem lasting decades ceases to be a “problem.” By then, the situation becomes “part of the culture.”
- More News Columns Headlines
-
STATE OF THE STATEHOUSE: Sentencing law could benefit juveniles
Tiger on Sergio: 'It's Time to Move On'
Robot Action Connected to Human Thought
Rain Damages Brazil Soccer Stadium
NYC 911 Call Lasts for 8 Hours
Obama: US Has Helped Syrian Rebels
California Cops Cruise on Stand-up Paddle Patrol
Falling Cable Hurts 10 NASCAR Fans
RAW: NSA Director Says 50 Plots Foiled
Raw: 100K Protesters Flood Brazilian Streets
Afghan Forces Take Afghanistan Security Lead
Obama: NSA Secret Data Gathering 'Transparent'
Raw: First Lady, Daughters Enjoy Irish Sights
Transgender Candidate Running in NYC
Man Who Disrupted Flight Ranted About CIA
Ex-NFL Star Chad Johnson Out of Jail
Feds: 7-Eleven Stores Exploited Immigrants
Today in History June 18
Oklahoma City Thunder Players Tour Moore
Iran's Rowhani Urges 'Path of Moderation'
Raw: NASCAR Driver Jason Leffler Dies in Wreck
Inside Kim Kardashian's Premature Labor
Raw: Huge Fire Near Yosemite National Park
Paige Butcher Scorches on Hawaii Beach
Video: worst way to load cargo onto a plane
Never-before-seen footage of '08 Times Square bomber
WATCH IT: Lil Wayne tramples American flag
Mariah Carey Looks Beautiful in a Tiny Cut-Out Swimsuit
Out of Control Boat Throws Passengers Overboard
See Lindsay Lohan in Rehab
Sofia Vergara Posts Perky Backside Pic in Thong
Gaga Ditches Her Crazy Couture
Caught on Tape: Teacher Accused of Beating Autistic Child
"Stay Classy" Campaign Aims to Curb Binge Drinking
Sesame Street Tackling Tough Topic Parents in Jail
Miss Utah Fumbles Interview Question
Deranged man claims Newark-bound flight was poisoned
Cameron Diaz and Kate Upton Show Off Their Amazing Bikini Bodies
NBA FINALS: Spurs Win Game 5, Lead Series
