TERRE HAUTE — Peyton Manning only seems like Spock with an $80-million arm.
He stands behind a row of teammates, scanning the alignment and movements of 11 rival defenders. He points and hollers instructions to his fellow Indianapolis Colts. He may change a blocker’s assignment, or alter a receiver’s route. He may see a gap in the opponents’ formation, and call an “audible” — a completely different play, drawn from hundreds in the Colts’ complex playbook — seconds before center Jeff Saturday snaps the ball.
Back in the pocket, with four violently huge guys trying to claw through his blockers, Manning glances at each of his receivers, one by one. Then, with a snarling defensive end closing in, Manning sees Reggie Wayne slip past the safety and zips a pass into Wayne’s outstretched arms for a 14-yard first down. Manning had all of 3.5 seconds to make that decision.
The logical choice? Perhaps. Some form of critical-thinking skill is apparent when Manning tries to see through the decoy moves of linebackers threatening to blitz. Critical thinkers are a highly sought-after commodity in the 21st-century business world. They are skeptical by nature, explained Kevin Christ, who teaches critical thinking skills as an economics professor at Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology.
To critical thinkers, knowledge is always provisional (or temporary).
Manning is skeptical of his foes, and aware that his understanding of their motives must evolve with each game.
But successful NFL quarterbacks such as the two pitted in today’s Super Bowl — Manning and New Orleans Saints star Drew Brees — also employ attributes Spock would find illogical. Gut instinct, and useful fear. (Of course, the $80-million arms help, too.)
Those qualities separate Manning, Brees, Joe Montana and Tom Brady from other pro QBs with perhaps even more athletic talent and intelligence. Trying to decide which receiver to throw to, those quarterbacks may feel slight tinges of fear — the fear of throwing an interception — as they check off those covered too closely. When Manning finds the open man, the sensation is positive, instead of fearful, and the pass is thrown.
Such gut instinct, and the taming of fear, can’t be controlled without lots of repetition.
“The ability to make decisions based on those slight bits of information in a split second takes years and years of practice,” Jonah Lehrer, author of the book, “How We Decide,” said in a telephone interview Thursday.
Mind, gut combine
No other team sport, as Lehrer — a neuroscientist and journalist — points out in “How We Decide,” depends more on the judgment of a single player than NFL football. Still, though Manning’s “football IQ” is often trumpeted, his decision-making prowess involves more than sheer intellect. The standard intelligence test given to all incoming NFL players, the Wonderlic, reveals why IQs don’t predict success for a QB.
The average score for quarterbacks is 24, according to a report in the New Orleans Times-Picayune, and Manning scored an impressive 28. His brother, Eli, got a 39. Recent first-round draft pick quarterbacks Alex Smith and Matt Leinart received 40 and 35, respectively. Hall of Famers Terry Bradshaw and Dan Marino got 15 and 14, respectively.
Obviously, the ability to accurately hurl a 60-yard pass and master calculus aren’t enough. You also must be able to solve the problem of rushing defensive linemen and predatory defensive backs while implementing a game plan (critical thinking), and then find the open receiver and hit him with a pass (controlled fear and gut instinct).
Clearly, with four NFL MVP Awards, Manning does that well.
“I don’t know if that’s critical thinking, or analytic decisions finely honed over time,” said Christ, who teaches critical-thinking skills.
“Within the small domain of decision-making — on the football field — [Manning] probably is a critical thinker,” Christ said.
One classic definition of critical thinking, by early 1900s Yale professor William Graham Sumner and relayed by Christ, defines it as “the examination and test of propositions of any kind, which are offered for acceptance, in order to find out whether they correspond to reality or not. The critical faculty is a product of education and training. It is a mental habit and power.”
For those of us with a Terry Bradshaw vocabulary, in a nutshell, critical thinkers have good B.S. detectors.
“They’re skeptics,” Christ said. “They don’t believe in absolute answers. They don’t see the world in blacks and whites, but the shades of gray they see don’t scare them.”
How does that apply to Manning, who will see black and gold on the other side of the line today?
Well, as Sumner wrote, critical thinking is man’s “only guarantee against delusion, deception, superstition and misapprehension of ourselves and our earthly circumstances.” And, as Christ explained, NFL “defenses are continually trying to delude and deceive quarterbacks, and Manning is obviously one of the best at seeing through the deceptions of defenses, and creating a few of his own.”
Even among the NFL’s elite critical thinkers and gut-instinct quarterbacks, Manning stands out.
“I do think Peyton Manning’s relatively unique as QBs go, in terms of his decision-making,” Lehrer said.
That sheer intelligence portion of that skill should not be over-emphasized, though. Brilliance happens at practice sessions. Instinct locates the right receiver late in the fourth quarter. “Critical decision-makers aren’t purely rational thinkers,” Christ said.
Rationality won’t stop a 300-pound defensive tackle. “If you’re a QB in the pocket, you don’t want to be thinking too much,” Lehrer said. “Even Peyton Manning doesn’t want to think too much, or he’s going to get sacked.
“I think Peyton Manning’s a little bit more aware than other QBs,” he added, “but he’s still relying on the ability to read pass patterns and defenses, and that’s developed over years.”
Learning to think
Such people aren’t freaks of nature, but they’re not in the majority.
“In absolute numbers, sure, there are plenty of them” in America, Christ said. “But there are 300 million of us, so in relative terms, there’s not that many.”
Those numbers can grow, said Aaron Preston, chairman of the philosophy department at Valparaiso University, where a Logic and Critical Thinking course is taught. “What we can say, with some confidence, I think, is that most of us have room for improvement as critical thinkers. How many of us regularly perform at the ‘Peyton Manning level’ in the critical thinking activities relevant to our jobs, our finances, our parenting, and so on?”
Training is necessary.
“I think our colleges need to do a better job of teaching our young people how to think, rather than training them for their first job,” Christ said.
Manning got an early start in his critical thinking education. “I don’t know whether the University of Tennessee [Peyton’s alma mater] taught him that, or if he learned it in his upbringing,” Christ said. “It’s probably in his DNA. I mean, he practically grew up in the New Orleans Saints’ huddle, with Archie Manning.” Archie, a former Saints quarterback and Peyton’s dad, is one of that long-suffering franchise’s few legends.
Archie got sacked 396 times in his career, playing for some really bad teams from 1971 to ’84. Only nine QBs in the history of the NFL have suffered more sacks. Apparently, young Peyton took good mental notes of his dad’s situation.
Mark Bennett can be reached at (812) 231-4377 or firstname.lastname@example.org.
MARK BENNETT: Colts quarterback Peyton Manning’s decision-making prowess involves more than sheer intellect
TERRE HAUTE — Peyton Manning only seems like Spock with an $80-million arm.
- Mark Bennett Opinion
Mark Bennett: High-profile mural connects historical dots from city to river
At 96 feet wide and 2 stories tall, the power, impact and value of the Wabash will be evident.
MARK BENNETT: Life at face value: Mom’s simple advice still presents a valuable daily challenge
Most moms don’t base their advice on scientific research.
(Unless, of course, your mother is a scientific researcher. If so, carry a No. 2 pencil and take good notes.)
MARK BENNETT: Should I stay or should I go?
Some have their Bill Clinton-era Cavalier packed (with the trunk bungee-ed shut), apartment cleaned (except for the fridge), and iPhone GPS locked onto the fastest route out of Terre Haute. Others are staying — until they find a better job, or because they’re starting a career here, or because this town feels like home. In each case, a new stage of life begins today.
College Class of '13 gets a little extra advice
Local college grads will hear commencement speakers offer life and career advice this month. We’re offering them an extra dose here from folks who’ve found success in various vocations and regions of the nation. Many have Terre Haute roots.
MARK BENNETT: Spirited response to a rising river
The power within the Wabash revealed itself last week.
MARK BENNETT: Littered with irony: Why do people callously discard their trash, and who are they?
Though they aren’t acknowledged by the U.S. Census Bureau, there are basically two demographic groups of people … Those who would dump their old toilet on the banks of the Wabash River or a rural roadside. And those who wouldn’t.
MARK BENNETT: Performing under the radar: Toiling for years behind the scenes, Terre Haute native J.T. Corenflos finally earned a splash of musical recognition
People who diligently work to make others shine are a rare breed.
Season of Day 2s arrives
Calendars in Cincinnati contain one extra holiday — Opening Day, traditionally the first Monday in April.
MARK BENNETT: Amid tragedy and chaos, the hopeful smiles of youth could not be repressed
The image jars the viewer. On its own, the old photograph appears ordinary. Three smiling kids.
MARK BENNETT: A century later, ‘On the Banks of the Wabash’ still rises above Indiana politics
Music and politics share one commonality — people who like a style different from yours are nuts.
MARK BENNETT: Digit dialing a thing of the past, but telephoning is still a numbers game
You’ve heard of child prodigies who can play Mozart on piano or perform calculus at the age of 5.
That wasn’t me.
MARK BENNETT: After years of preparation, 60 immigrants will gather in Terre Haute on March 14 to pledge their allegiance to the United States of America
It will have been a long and difficult road, but it will be an emotional moment when they raise their right hands and begin the oath of citizenship
MARK BENNETT: The fall and rise of a ‘Young Titan’
Broken. Humiliated. Discarded. Finished.
Few of us think of Winston Churchill in such bleak terms.
MARK BENNETT: Trying to keep momentum of acceptance within the community a key part of Jeff Lorick’s job
Second-graders’ eyes and minds function differently.
They see the future unjaded. Their possibilities stand tall, not yet choked by the adult weeds of prejudice and bitterness.
MARK BENNETT: For Glenda Ritz, being educator, ‘not a politician’ still makes good political sense
Educator, not a politician.
Glenda Ritz emphasizes that distinction about herself.
MARK BENNETT: Falling short of the big prize will produce lessons nonetheless
This is a day for Roman numerals.
Americans seldom use them. And when we do, humility is not our purpose.
MARK BENNETT: Forgotten Message: Advice from ‘The Mick’ should be remembered in wake of Lance Armstrong’s troubles
The two comments were almost identical.
MARK BENNETT: A sense of Americana constant passenger as iconic Corvette motors through milestone birthday
On my last ride at the wheel of a ’Vette, I was a wide-eyed teenager, guiding my brother’s almost-new, orange 1976 model.
MARK BENNETT: Sculptor from North Carolina to capture image of Indiana’s first black state legislator
Well-meaning parents try to instill strong character in their kids.
“Don’t be afraid to stand up for your beliefs,” moms and dads will insist, “even if you stand alone.”
MARK BENNETT: Heart ailments, avoidable health issues affect high numbers of Vigo residents
Many folks in Vigo County will analyze digits on their bathroom scales this month. After all, January and fitness resolutions are traditional partners.
MARK BENNETT: For some people in the Wabash Valley, happy holidays require a little help
Picture yourself as a kid, not yet 5 years old, growing up in a small house in Terre Haute.
MARK BENNETT: Beware Ignorance and Want and reap the benefits of early education
Pretend that Charles Dickens is about to become Indiana’s next governor.
MARK BENNETT: In spirit of season, calculate your fiscal cliff impact, then argue
Envision “chestnuts roasting on an open fire.”
MARK BENNETT: Members of Congress should be free to consider all sides of an issue
Attempting to trump the U.S. Constitution requires some nerve.
MARK BENNETT: An unbudging Congress standing on opposing sides accomplishes little
Sausage patties, hugging a scoop of scrambled eggs and a couple slices of toast on a plate, and chased with nearby steaming black coffee.
MARK BENNETT: Hoosier voters issue mandate on Bennett’s school reforms
Mike Pence, Mitch Daniels and Indiana legislators should respect the votes of 1,315,026 Hoosiers.
MARK BENNETT: Elections, governing would look a lot different if everybody voted
A raffle ticket purchase usually comes with a disclaimer — “you must be present to win.”
MARK BENNETT: On Election Day, as Vigo County goes, so goes the United States
Hempstead sounds like a fine place.
MARK BENNETT: Upcoming PBS documentary focuses on nation’s voting irregularities, through Hoosier eyes
As America prepares to choose its governmental leaders, voters are being relentlessly asked how much they trust elected officials.
MARK BENNETT: Quest for knowledge keeps going as Elliott Gould prepares to speak in Terre Haute
As our conversation began, Elliott Gould was in the midst of learning. He was reading a book.
- More Mark Bennett Opinion Headlines
- Mark Bennett: High-profile mural connects historical dots from city to river