There is no debate over one aspect of Indiana lawmakers considering a statewide ban on smoking in indoor public places.
Their decision can’t possibly please everyone.
“No. Never,” said Charlie Brown, a state representative from Gary.
Despite the inevitable conflict, the General Assembly needs to tackle the issue when its session begins in January. If they can spend ample time crafting a logical and pragmatic law to protect workers and the general public from secondhand smoke, the legislators should follow through and do just that. Indiana risks cementing its reputation as an unhealthy state with high smoking, heart disease and cancer rates. Prospective businesses pay attention to health-care costs.
This state also has a hodge-podge of ordinances, with varying levels of restrictions, in 36 counties or communities. Vigo County has one of the least restrictive, while Bloomington’s is far more comprehensive. Some towns in between have no ordinance.
Brown, who tried unsuccessfully to introduce a statewide smoking ban with various exemptions in the short 2008, thinks Indiana needs a uniform law. “Look at the confusion as you travel from community to community,” he said in a telephone interview earlier this month.
He’s right. The difference in local ordinances and the state’s weak health status are two elements of a complex issue. Brown wants to introduce a broader statewide ban in the upcoming session with no exemptions for bars, bowling alleys, casinos and horse racing tracks. He asked House Speaker Pat Bauer, a fellow Democrat, to assign the smoking bill to the Public Health Committee of which Brown is the chairman.
If his bill gets traction and actually moves forward in this session, advocates for casinos, restaurants, bars, bowlers and pari-mutuel venues will quickly line up in opposition. Brown is aware of that. “My endeavor is to have smoke-free everywhere,” he said, “but in the Indiana General Assembly there is always the friendly art of compromise.”
It’s important that those compromises get a thorough review by legislators, and not get thrown into a diluted law. The session ahead features many difficult decisions. The economic crunch threatens local governments, libraries, schools and colleges, especially as lawmakers ponder the permanence of property tax caps. Those fiscal problems rightly merit lengthy discussion and analysis. Even though the 2009 session is a long one, a public indoor smoking law should not be dealt with as an afterthought. If funding problems facing the state and its municipalities dominates the session, then the bill on smoke-free workplaces may have to wait until 2010.
To be sure, the state is behind others on this health issue. According to The Associated Press, 29 states, Puerto Rico and the District of Columbia have smoke-free laws. Next year, Montana, Nebraska, Oregon and Utah will join that list.
The dangers of secondhand smoke are clear and costly. A common rationalization for no smoking restrictions is that employees can choose where they want to work. Brown, though, worries that especially in this tight economy, some workers have no other options. He also aptly points out that taxpayer-supported medical assistance often is needed to treat people with smoking-related illnesses and diseases.
“What percentage of smokers have commercial insurance coverage, and what percentage don’t and will have to rely on public support for their health care?” Brown said.
That dilemma deserves a full hearing in the Indiana Legislature. If Hoosier lawmakers can devote the proper amount of time to that debate in 2009, they should make that commitment and pass a smart, fair smoke-free workplace law. If they’re overwhelmed by economic issues, then it’s better to take up the smoking debate in 2010, rather than passing a half-hearted law now.
Mark Bennett can be reached at mark.bennett@tribstar.com or (812) 231-4377.
Mark Bennett Opinion
Mark Bennett: Difference in local ordinances, Indiana’s weak health status are two elements to consider when looking at statewide smoking ban
- Mark Bennett Opinion
-
-
MARK BENNETT: Stuck in the middle with you
Thank goodness, members of Congress do not drive in the Indianapolis 500.
-
MARK BENNETT: Roadway Role Models: Adults need to remember habits often rub off on teens
Plenty of dads connected with a car ad that first aired on TV two years ago.
-
MARK BENNETT: Farmers using no-till and cover crops doing their part to keep soil healthy
Earth Day typically features community cleanups, and discussions of air and water pollution. All deserve the attention.
-
MARK BENNETT: Lyrical legacy
Traditions begin, end, revive and evolve.
-
MARK BENNETT: GOP campaign fireworks could fizzle for Hoosiers once again
Of all the United States, Indiana deserves to experience Republican-on-Republican presidential attack-ad mania.
-
MARK BENNETT: Hard hit: Cash rewards for game-ending hits on NFL players are not a part of the game
The moaning and whining miss the point.
-
MARK BENNETT: Vigo County native helping relief agency provide physical, spiritual aid to Japan in wake of last year’s devastation
Help can be harder to receive than give.
-
MARK BENNETT: Perception of Wabash River’s water quality doesn’t always match reality
People like chocolate milk. In a glass. Fresh from the fridge.
-
MARK BENNETT: Filling a Need: Vigo County YMCA expected to open this spring
Comebacks inspire hope. They also require lots of work.
-
MARK BENNETT: Favorable images
Movie critics take a lot of criticism.
-
MARK BENNETT: Toxic victories
When the Super Bowl ends tonight in Indianapolis, most of the Giants and Patriots will shake hands, despite their competitive fire, win or lose.
-
MARK BENNETT: Indianapolis will be on display for the nation with the Super Bowl coming to town
Someone immersed in a crash diet to make a smashing impression at a class reunion may get the desired effect.
-
MARK BENNETT: Patiently waiting for Indiana's primary
While standing in a check-in line at Leonardo da Vinci Airport in Rome a few years ago, I watched an Italian woman walk past dozens of more patient travelers to grab a spot up front.
-
MARK BENNETT: Processing postal change
You probably know one of those 10,026.
-
MARK BENNETT: Multiple choice question: Voters must choose which direction they want the future of education to go
There was a time when few Hoosiers outside of education circles could name the state superintendent of public instruction.
-
MARK BENNETT: With an historic election behind Terre Haute, it’s time to look at the future’s possibilities
Everybody knows their “woulda, coulda, shoulda” moments.
-
MARK BENNETT: Economic forecast: Things looking up but don’t expect ‘much of a dent in unemployment’
Outside the Columbia Club, the atmosphere matched the picture of 2012 painted by a panel of economists for an audience of business people gathered inside that ritzy building on Monument Circle in Indianapolis.
-
MARK BENNETT: Students who reach for a college education too often are buried under a pile of debt
Right now, millions of college graduates are wondering whether their education was worth the effort.
That doubt hurts the country. -
MARK BENNETT: Tangier’s festival volunteers keep past alive for future
Traditions stay alive only as long as the people who hold them dear.
Small towns have that same life expectancy. -
MARK BENNETT: Made in the USA? A political T-shirt faux pas
The most rational statement about a small furor in the U.S. Senate campaign was uttered by a tea party organizer.
-
MARK BENNETT: Daniels goes where a candidate probably won’t in new book
Some things simply won’t get said on the political campaign trail.
-
MARK BENNETT: Time waits for no Manning
Sad, disappointed and uncertain. Colts fans feel all of those.
-
MARK BENNETT: Value of every minute deeply realized on 9/11 (related VIDEO)
Editor’s Note
This summer, the Tribune-Star’s Mark Bennett visited New York City, Washington, D.C., and Shanksville, Pa., sites where the terror attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, are now memorialized. He observed the cityscapes and landscapes forever changed by the events of that day and talked with people he encountered there, many of whom witnessed the attacks and their aftermath from close range and had personal ties to its victims. -
MARK BENNETT: As school begins, carve out daily time
By now, most back-to-school checklists are tattered and creased.
-
MARK BENNETT: Movie scene shows Terre Haute accepting Debs' role in its history
You stay classy, Terre Haute.
-
MARK BENNETT: Community outpouring represents collective sympathy for fallen officer
Every Terre Haute resident has probably been asked the same question.
“Why do you live there?” -
MARK BENNETT: Declaration of cursive’s death reminiscent of ’70s metric-conversion mania
When the state of Indiana announced it would no longer require schools to teach cursive handwriting, I was LOL.
-
MARK BENNETT: On Fourth of July, remember, too, those we depend on
A spatula in one hand, a cool beverage in the other, and a stash of bottle rockets in a plastic sack in the garage.
-
MARK BENNETT: Get out and see what the Valley has to offer
Maybe you drive the same route to work every day. Shortest route. Saves time and a few dimes worth of gas.
-
MARK BENNETT: Walking the fine bipartisan line
Lugar’s occasional departures from hard-line conservatism have put his six-term Senate position in jeopardy.
- More Mark Bennett Opinion Headlines
-
MARK BENNETT: Stuck in the middle with you
Man Falls Off Crane, Dies After Police Standoff
Witness Describes Fla. Face-chewing Attack
Unexpected Smog in Pristine National Parks
Raw Video: Cop Shoots Man Eating Another's Face
Obama Honors Fallen Troops at Arlington Cemetery
Man in Crane at Texas College Says He's Armed
Dairy Farm Uses Chiropractor to Help Cows
Raw Video: Deadly Explosion at Minn. Paper Mill
Russia Condemns Ally Syria Over Massacre of 108
Romney Promises World's Strongest Military
Air Canada Plane Makes Emergency Landing
Romney Campaigns Ahead of Claiming Nomination
Diplomatic Expulsions Follow Fresh Syria Report
Raw Video: Earthquake Shakes Evacuees in Italy
15 Dead in Northern Italy's 5.8-magnitude Quake
Obama Pays Tribute to Vietnam Veterans
Panetta: Asia the 'Project' for New Navy Grads
Beryl Knocks Out Power in Florida
Raw Video: Memorial Day Aboard Intrepid
New Ticks Spread Across Southeast, Diseases Rise
Los Angeles Bar Bans Bachelorettes
Hamster Plays Dead
Beyonce Shows Off 60 Pound Weight Loss at Concert
Drunk Women Breaking Into Houses: A New Trend?
LeAnn Rimes Rocks Short Shorts
Gordon Ramsay Carried Off Field
Man Dies Getting Lap Dance
Kim Kardashian Claims Items Stolen from Her Luggage
Bear cools off in Calif. family's pool
Ep. 3: Chopped Desserts
Air Force dad surprises family at baseball game
Justin Bieber Wanted for Questioning for L.A. Scuffle
J.Lo and Marc's Friendly Reunion
Jet makes emergency landing after debris falls off
Cynthia Nixon Ties the Knot
Woman, 80, Falls Out of Skydive Harness Mid-Jump
Keira Reveals Engagement Ring
