TERRE HAUTE —
A Terre Haute man has been sentenced to 10 years in prison for the December 2010 neglect death of his disabled halfbrother.
Joseph Rheubottom, 53, indicated he will appeal the sentence set Wednesday in Vigo Superior Court 1 by Judge John Roach after hearing two hours of arguments and testimony.
Rheubottom pleaded guilty in March to neglect of a dependent resulting in serious bodily injury, a class-B felony which carries a sentencing range of six to 20 years.
Rheubottom and his wife, Melissa, 42, were arrested by Terre Haute Police after an investigation into the death of James Cliff, 46, whose living conditions were deemed “horrid” by police.
Cliff resided with the couple in the 300 block of North 14th Street. They were the primary caregivers of the paraplegic man, who had moved in with the couple about a year before his death on Dec. 4 at Union Hospital.
An autopsy noted that Cliff had multiple open wounds, including one on his right hip where bare bone was exposed. The autopsy determined that infection from the wounds caused Cliff to contract pneumonia, which caused his death. Vigo County Coroner Dr. Roland Kohr ruled Cliff’s death a homicide.
Kohr testified Tuesday that Cliff’s condition indicated neglect had been going on for several months, but some of the issues could have been resolved with medical treatment.
Deputy Prosecutor Carroll Smeltzer introduced photographs into evidence showing the living conditions inside the house were unsanitary.
Police reported at the time of the arrests that the roach-infested house — which was also home to several cats, dogs and a bird — had animal feces on the floor of the residence, as well as human feces in Cliff’s wheelchair, and on the couch and bed where he slept. Police also saw rotting food in the kitchen, and described an overwhelmingly foul odor in the home.
“We found the house to be in very, very, very poor condition,” THPD Detective Cpl. Darren Long testified.
A relative of Cliff, Joyce Setters, also testified that she saw Cliff less than a month before he moved in with the Rheubottoms in December 2009. The next time that she saw him was in the hospital when he died, she said, and she did not recognize him.
“I just don’t understand why it happened. I really don’t,” Setters said.
Rheubottom took the witness stand as well, saying that he was close to his halfbrother, and that he is remorseful about Cliff’s death.
“I’d trade places with him if I could,” Rheubottom said, later stating, “I miss him very much.”
Rheubottom said that because he could no longer work due to his heart condition, he was the primary caregiver for Cliff, while his wife worked. Rheubottom also said he made a promise to Cliff not to take him to a doctor for medical treatment and not to place him into a nursing home.
Melissa Rheubottom also pleaded guilty in March to the same class-D felony charge. She received a six-year prison sentence.
Defense attorney James Organ requested a six-year sentence for his client, and asked that Joseph Rheubottom be considered for the work release program or in-home detention through Vigo County Community Corrections. Roach rejected those requests, noting that Rheubottom was disabled after a heart attack which left him unable to work or to afford the fees associated with community corrections.
Joseph Rheubottom’s plea agreement left the sentencing open to argument in front of Roach, who imposed the advisory sentence of 10 years.
Roach said that Cliff’s care and living conditions were “deplorable,” and said that Rheubottom had the responsibility to seek medical care for Cliff despite any promises not to do that.
“Most of us wouldn’t allow our animals to live in such conditions,” Roach said.
Lisa Trigg can be reached at (812) 231-4254 or lisa.trigg@tribstar.com.
Local & Bistate
Man sentenced to 10 years in neglect death of halfbrother
Judge describes living conditions for paraplegic victim as ‘deplorable’
- Local & Bistate
-
-
Vigo County Jail Log: May 21, 2013
The following individuals were booked into the Vigo County Jail by area law enforcement on Monday and Tuesday, based on jail records.
-
UPDATE: Damage surveys show 2 weak tornadoes hit near Indy
INDIANAPOLIS — The National Weather Service says storm surveys show two weak tornadoes struck central Indiana.
-
Storm causes scattered Indiana power outages
INDIANAPOLIS — A line of thunderstorms that moved across Indiana caused scattered building damage and power outages for several thousand homes and businesses.
-
Kindergartner diagnosed with MD treated to a day with the fire department
“He’ll just never forget this day,” Stacey Manley said, a little bit tearfully, as she watched her smiling 6-year-old son Carter sitting happily in the captain’s seat of Fire Engine 2.
-
Casey, Illinois aims for another world record
The town of Casey, Ill., may soon weave its way into the record books as the small town with the most world records. After setting records for the world’s largest wind chimes and the world’s largest golf tee, Casey is now looking to become home to the world’s largest knitting needles and crochet hook.
-
Rose-Hulman projects will promote growth, learning for people with physical challenges
Life changed dramatically for college engineering student Drew Christy on Feb. 22, 2008 when he was involved in an auto accident and suffered a traumatic brain injury.
-
‘500’ gas stations being sold to Speedway LLC
After several decades in business, the area’s familiar “500” gasoline stations and convenience stores will soon be missing from the roadsides of Vigo and Sullivan counties.
-
Terre Haute woman faces 14 charges
A Terre Haute woman faces 14 criminal counts after her arrest Friday on drug-related charges.
-
Two adults injured in ATV accident
Two adults were injured Sunday evening while riding an all-terrain vehicle near Lexington Farms Subdivision off Moyer Drive in southern Vigo County.
-
Vigo schools’ medical claims down 4 percent
The Vigo County School Corp.’s medical claims were about $13 million over the last 12 months, down 4 percent from the prior year, said Diane Titchenell, an Anthem account manager that works with the school district.
-
2013 Government Directory now available
The 2013 Government Directory is now available.
-
UPDATE: 5 killed, 6 injured in I-70 van crash in Illinois
ST. LOUIS — A van carrying church members returning from a California gathering careened off of a southern Illinois freeway and overturned several times today, killing five people and sending six others to hospitals, authorities said.
-
2 children reported dead from Indianapolis fire
INDIANAPOLIS — Authorities say some autistic children lived in the Indianapolis condominium unit where a fire has killed two children.
-
Tighter Indiana drunken driving law seems unlikely
INDIANAPOLIS — Some key Indiana legislators say it’s unlikely that the state will any time soon go along with a federal safety board’s recommendation that the threshold for drunken driving be cut nearly in half.
-
Vigo County Jail Log: May 20, 2013
The following individuals were booked into the Vigo County Jail by area law enforcement on Friday, Saturday, Sunday and Monday, based on jail records.
-
Life-Size Ping Pong: Valley pickleball tourney draws large crowd to Brittlebank Park
It’s been described as “ping pong on steroids.”
Some people call it “life-size ping pong where you stand on the table.” -
Boat trip aims to raise awareness about Lewy Body Dementia
In 2013, the Year of the River, it makes sense to link a grand adventure on the Wabash River with a good cause.
-
Legislature had little taste for alcohol bills
When it comes to alcohol, the 2013 legislative session may be marked more by what it didn’t do to boost booze sales than what it did.
-
STATE OF THE STATEHOUSE: Is it regulation that doesn’t make sense or evening the playing field?
I’m not much of a drinker, so I haven’t spent much time thinking about how Indiana’s alcohol laws personally impact me, but that changed last fall when my daughter got married.
-
RESTAURANT INSPECTIONS: April 29-May 3
The Vigo County Health Department inspected the following food establishments April 29-May 3:
-
For Piper: Annual ‘Rush the Punter’ event dedicated to Dixie Bee student who died Wednesday after a short illness
Steve Weatherford’s “Rush the Punter” fundraiser at Fairbanks Park on Saturday was dedicated to a little girl who lost her life unexpectedly to pneumonia.
-
Vigo schools prepare to tighten belts
State funding for the Vigo County School Corp. will remain “pretty flat” for the next two years, said Donna Wilson, chief financial officer.
-
Veterans take to the trees
Cristal Bednar took photos of her husband, Justin, as he laboriously climbed his way up a “Dangle-Duo” to get to a zipline at Indiana State University’s Sycamore Outdoor Center.
-
Property owner seeks halt to Hulman Lake dam project
A Terre Haute property owner is seeking an injunction that would at least temporarily halt the city’s work on the Hulman Lake dam project.
-
Tornado veterans balance preparedness, practicality
Few things in nature are less predictable than a tornado. They can form quickly. They strike weirdly, leveling one building while leaving its neighbor untouched. They can fling a car a half-mile and turn a piece of lumber into a wall-piercing missile.
-
ISU unveils interactive Bayh Family Legacy Wall at school
A who’s who of Indiana Democrats paid tribute to Evan Bayh and several generations of the Bayh family Friday during a dedication of a new interactive display at Indiana State University.
-
Can you smell me now?
A contraband cell phone has been discovered by the Vigo County Jail’s youngest and most unique officer.
-
GIVING BACK: Steve Weatherford buys shoes for kids day before charity run
Terre Haute’s Steve Weatherford, punter for the 2012 Super Bowl champion New York Giants, showed once again his generosity Friday by donating new athletic shoes to more than two dozen Vigo County kids.
-
N.Y. Giants honor Weatherford as ‘Man of the Year’
Dan Tanoos, superintendent of Vigo County schools, remembers the first time he saw Steve Weatherford as a freshman at Terre Haute North Vigo High School.
-
Sunday recital at The Woods
A recital featuring songs from well-known composers is at 7 p.m. Sunday in the Church of the Immaculate Conception at Saint Mary-of-the-Woods.
- More Local & Bistate Headlines
-
Vigo County Jail Log: May 21, 2013
Raw: Aerials Show Path of Oklahoma Destruction
Raw: Massive Funnel Clouds in Oklahoma
Raw: Widespread Destruction in Moore, Okla.
Raw: Tearful Reunion After Okla. Tornado
AP Photograher: 'It Was a Miracle' They Got Out
Obama Pledges Urgent Aid for Tornado Victims
Raw: Crews Search for Survivors of Okla. Tornado
Moore, Okla. City of Reunions, Tears After Storm
OKC Hospital Describes Treating Tornado Wounded
Active Search for Utah Missing Mom Ends
Tim Cook Defends Apple's Tax Accounting
Arias Tells Jury What She'd Do if She Gets Life
Voters Could Elect LA's First Female Mayor
Raw: Tornado on the Ground in Oklahoma
Raw: Rescue Workers Search Oklahoma School
Raw: Japan's WWII Atrocities Under Fire in Seoul
Raw: Rescuers Pull Tornado Survivors to Safety
Huge Tornado Kills Dozens Near Oklahoma City
Gov. Fallin: Okla. Facing Horrific Disaster
Reunited Dad, Son: 'We Just Praise God'
Kate Middleton's Dress Flies Up
VIRAL: Baby makes epic soccer goal
The Hangover Baby All Grown Up
Olivia Munn Flaunts Her Bikini Bod
Britney Spears Under Fire Once Again For Being A Bad Mom
The all-new Xbox One
RAW: Massive tornado strikes Oklahoma
Nidal Hasan paid $278K while awaiting trial
VIDEO: Teacher reunites mother and son after tornado levels elementary school in Oklahoma City
Okla. tornado survivor finds dog buried alive under rubble
Jennifer Lawrence Gets Naked and Painted Blue as X-Men's Mystique
Pickler's Dance Moves Cause A Stir
Obama to tornado survivors: The country stands beside you
Reporter Cries Over Devastation
Sneak Peek: 'Modern Family' Says Good Bye
Trailer: 'The Last Stand' Available on Blu-ray Disc, DVD, Digital Download
IWitness Look at Moore, OK Tornado
RAW: Moore, OK tornado touches down near school
Robert Pattinson Moves Out
