Local & Bistate
The CSI effect: Coroner Dr. Roland Kohr shares his reasons for hating the popular TV show
TERRE HAUTE — Vigo County Coroner Roland M. Kohr hates CSI – the popular TV programs about solving often bizarre murders.
Thanks to CSI, people have a completely unrealistic idea of what crime-scene investigations are really like, Kohr said.
Kohr, who is in his third term as Vigo County coroner, shared the “top 10 reasons I hate CSI” with an audience of about 50 people Monday at the Vigo County Public Library’s Southland branch.
“The public actually believes this stuff” was reason No. 3 Kohr said he hates CSI.
Thanks to CSI, jurors and the news media expect investigators to do sophisticated, time-consuming and expensive tests in more and more cases, Kohr said. This means jurors often demand sophisticated evidence, such as DNA analysis, before finding someone guilty, he noted.
Kohr mentioned one case in which a jury wanted fingerprint evidence despite having a suspect who confessed and was caught with stolen property.
“Juries think it should be as it is on TV,” Kohr said. “In trials, you spend a lot of time refuting the CSI effect,” he said.
Also, CSI makes real scientific testing look quick and easy, Kohr said. In real life, tests can take weeks or months to complete and are very expensive.
Even toxicology tests must be sent away and can take up to two weeks to return, Kohr said. On CSI they take just minutes, he said.
With a budget of just $125,000 per year, the Vigo County Coroner’s office is limited in what tests it can seek, he said. “If we did every test we could think of, we could do about five cases a year,” he said.
There were around 125 coroner’s cases in Vigo County last year, Kohr noted.
Other reasons Kohr said he hates CSI include an overuse of smart-sounding acronyms, the frequent use of flashlights when just turning on the lights would make things a lot easier and the fact that the fictional investigators seem to do everything themselves from testing blood stains to interrogating witnesses.
In real-life cases, several people and organizations are involved, Kohr noted. In one recent Sullivan County case, at least eight different organizations and individuals, including outside experts on blood splattering, were involved, he said.
Having different organizations involved in real-life cases also means “turf wars” can break out, Kohr noted. This is largely ignored by CSI, he said.
An additional problem with CSI, Kohr noted, is that the fictional bad guys often confess.
“It just doesn’t work that way,” Kohr said. “In real life there are attorneys” and highly paid expert witnesses who will say almost anything for a fee, he said.
In addition to his top ten list, Kohr showed the audience photographs of crime scenes and victims and diagrams of gunshot wounds, knife wounds and other injuries. He explained how wounds can tell investigators, for example, whether a gun was discharged at close range or not.
Kohr also told the audience that Indiana might do well to adopt a medical examiners’ system to replace county coroners, which exists in all of Indiana’s 92 counties. While Kohr is a certified forensic pathologist, he is the only coroner in the state with those credentials. The only constitutional qualification to serve as coroner in Indiana is that you must be at least age 18, Kohr noted.
Only about 5 percent of the cases Kohr sees are homicide cases, he noted. But on CSI, “virtually everything is a bizarre murder,” he said. “People think CSI is real. It’s not like it is on TV.”
Arthur Foulkes can be reached at (812) 231-4232 or arthur.foulkes@tribstar.com.
- Local & Bistate
-
-
Early Tuesday shooting injures man in hand
An early-Tuesday shooting outside a Terre Haute pub has left one man with a wounded hand.
Investigation is continuing into the 3:45 a.m. shooting outside the Dawg House Pub and Grille, 830 Oak St. -
Wabash Valley inmates build children’s playhouse
The Wabash Valley Correctional Facility Building Trades Class has a special gift for Carlisle Elementary School – a playhouse for the students.
-
New trial date set for Ebb Howard
A Sept. 14 trial date has been set for a Terre Haute man charged with 21 counts of burglary and receiving stolen property, in addition to meth-related charges.
-
Terre Haute attorneys competing to raise food, donations for charities
Terre Haute attorneys are going to see who can set the bar the highest in a competition designed to help hungry families.
-
JA inducts new hall of fame class
Rising stars, champions, educators and volunteers were inducted into the Junior Achievement of the Wabash Valley Hall of Fame on Tuesday night.
-
Officials identify body found in eastern Vigo woods
Dental records have been used to confirm that a body found Sunday in northeastern Vigo County is that of Charles Raymond Chumley Jr., 30, of Brazil, who went missing in that area Dec. 8.
-
Educator had big impact in Vigo schools
Those who knew Julie McLaughlin say her kindness, concern and positive attitude had a huge impact on Vigo County School Corp. students and staff.
-
Vigo property taxes down about $15M
County and city government, schools, airport, library, a sanitary district and other taxing units in Vigo County will see total property tax revenues reduced by more than $15 million for 2010.
-
Sharing a link, not a rivalry
Normally, students from Terre Haute North Vigo, South Vigo and West Vigo high schools want to beat each other’s teams.
On Monday, they worked to build teams. -
Walgreens wants to sell alcohol, wine in order to compete with CVS
Beer and wine may soon hit the shelves at Walgreens in Vigo County as early as May, the first time alcohol would be available at the pharmacy stores in the county.
- More Local & Bistate Headlines
-
Early Tuesday shooting injures man in hand
