Using a law passed last year aimed at giving people a second chance, hundreds of Indiana residents with years-old arrests for low-level crimes have been granted court orders shielding their criminal histories from employers.
The law has been hailed as a success, but there’s no guarantee yet that sealed-off information won’t show up on employment background checks that are conducted by third parties.
Earlier this year, the Indiana General Assembly passed a subsequent law that bars companies that buy and sell data used by employers in hiring decisions from releasing criminal records that have been shielded by the court.
But the law doesn’t go into effect until July 2013. And there is some concern now that those private background-check companies will try to get the legislature to roll back the law before then, citing the difficulties and expense of updating computerized criminal records that they buy by the bulk and collect by the millions.
Later this month, a legislative study committee is slated to take up the issue. In passing the legislation to regulate what those private background check companies can release, lawmakers agreed to delay its implementation until 2013 to give those companies a chance to voice their concerns to legislators.
Backers of the 2011 law that allows for the shielding of some criminal records, say the law was intended to make it easier for people with years-old, nonviolent, low-level offenses to get a job. To date, the Indiana State Police has received hundreds of court orders requiring it to remove nearly 1,700 criminal records from public access.
“Our intention was to give people who had made a mistake in their past and who had worked to redeem themselves a second chance,” said state Rep. Eric Turner, a Republican from Cicero who co-authored the bipartisan bill. “It undermines our intent if the information that is supposed to be shielded is being released because of mistakes by a third party,” Turner said.
For Indiana residents who’ve taken advantage of the 2011 law that gave them a legal right to shield some criminal records from employers, the issue is critical.
In April, the National Consumer Law Center, an advocacy organization, released a report that said an increasing number of background employment checks are error-filled because millions of criminal records are being collected digitally and not updated or checked for accuracy.
The report cites multiple examples of errors, including those involving job candidates who had been charged with a crime and later exonerated, but only the criminal charge showed up on the record. The center also found examples of people whose court records were expunged or sealed, but the information still showed up in their employment background checks.
“It’s heart-breaking for someone who thinks he’s been given a second chance to find out that’s not really true,” said Persis Yu, the National Consumer Law Center attorney who authored the report. “It certainly undermines their faith in the judicial system.”
State Rep. Jud McMillin, a Republican from Brookville, has been both a prosecutor and a defense attorney. He supports the 2011 law that allows people to have their arrest records shielded, and he’s convinced that third-party data collectors can comply with the state’s requirements that they maintain accurate records.
“They’ve told us they can do this, that they have the right technology,” McMillin said. “We need to hold them to their word.”
State Rep. Greg Steuerwald, an Avon Republican and an attorney, chairs the House Courts and Criminal Code committee where the issue will be discussed on Aug. 23. Steuerwald said he also supports the law. “We just need to make sure it does what we intended it to do.”
A spokesman for Lexis-Nexis, one of the world’s biggest providers of background information to employers, declined to comment on the company’s concerns about what the Indiana law will require the company to do when it goes into effect next year.
There is already a federal law, the Fair Credit Reporting Act, that requires companies that collect and sell background information to employers to keep their records updated and accurate. But in its April study, the National Consumer Law Center said the industry is largely unregulated and infrequently policed.
On Wednesday, the Federal Trade Commission announced that one of the biggest employment background screening companies, HireRight Solutions, agreed to pay $2.6 million to settle FTC charges that it violated the Fair Credit Reporting Act by failing to use reasonable procedures to assure the accuracy of the criminal history information it sold to employers.
It was the first time the FTC has charged an employment background screening firm with violating the federal law. The FTC said HireRight Solutions sold information to employers that included criminal history records that had been expunged or sealed; failed to prevent the same criminal offense information from being included in a background report multiple times; and failed to follow reasonable procedures to prevent obviously inaccurate consumer report information from being provided to employers.
Maureen Hayden is the Indiana Statehouse bureau chief for CNHI, the parent company of the Tribune-Star. She can be reached at email@example.com.
State’s criminal-records shield law doesn’t stop release of information
- Local & Bistate
Lane restrictions next week on U.S. 41 at Shelburn
SHELBURN, Ind. – Motorists should expect minimal delays because of lane restrictions for U.S. 41 in Sullivan County next week as the railroad company makes repairs to the rail crossing 1.2 miles north of Shelburn.
Reputed Mafioso tip triggers new Hoffa body search
OAKLAND TOWNSHIP, Mich. — The FBI saw enough merit in a reputed Mafia captain’s tip to once again break out the digging equipment to search for the remains of former Teamsters union leader Jimmy Hoffa, last seen alive before a lunch meeting with two mobsters nearly 40 years ago.
UPDATE: Parke County homicide victim identified
ROSEDALE — The victim in a Parke County homicide that occurred last week has been identified as Kathryn A. Bays, 55, of Rosedale.
Court lets walk-out fines against House Democrats stand
INDIANAPOLIS — House Democrats who had to pay more than $100,000 in fines after they walked out of the Indiana Statehouse won’t get the help they sought from the Indiana Supreme Court.
Vigo County Jail Log: June 18, 2013
The following individuals were booked into the Vigo County Jail by area law enforcement on Monday and Tuesday, based on jail records.
Back home again: Items from vaudeville stage and Terre Haute native sent to Historical Society
The staff at the Vigo County Historical Museum are excited about the arrival of priceless items used by Terre Haute-native Rose Fehrenbach and her husband, Edward Pierce, to promote their Vaudeville acts in the early 20th century.
Husband charged in Archer homicide
Terre Haute Police have found local reports of domestic violence between a Terre Haute man and his wife, whose body was discovered wrapped in a tarp and dumped in an Ohio ditch.
National Road panels dedicated
Rewind to the mid-1800s, when the trotting of a horse and buggy on National Road could be heard alongside the voices of people heading west, searching for opportunities.
Pence sets agency priorities
Following a directive from Gov. Mike Pence, state agency heads are reorganizing some of their top priorities to better reflect the first-year governor’s “roadmap for Indiana” plan for improving the state’s economy, infrastructure and health.
Another I-70 traffic snarl: Three injured in two related crashes
Three people were injured Monday afternoon from a pair of crashes on Interstate 70 that temporarily closed the highway and diverted traffic into Terre Haute.
Terre Haute man still hospitalized after scooter/car crash
A Terre Haute man remained hospitalized Monday at Methodist Hospital in Indianapolis after his scooter struck a car early Saturday on Wabash Avenue at 25th Street.
Overpass repairs causing Interstate 70 lane restrictions
Repairs to the Frye Road overpass in southeastern Vigo County has caused a restriction to the left lane of Interstate 70 between the 13- and 14-mile markers, about two miles east of the Indiana 46 exit.
Indiana woman condemned for killing at 15 is freed
A woman who was sentenced to death at age 16 for taking part in the torture and murder of a 78-year-old Bible studies teacher was released from an Indiana prison Monday after growing to middle age behind bars.
Grant will let Vigo Library evaluate map collection
The Vigo County Public Library has received a $2,000 grant to evaluate its historic map collection, a library official announced Monday.
Four juveniles caught on elementary school roof; one injured jumping off
Police say a juvenile was lucky to have suffered only a broken leg after jumping from the roof of a Vigo County elementary school – dropping about 30 feet to the ground.
Farmersburg man sentenced after guilty plea in rape case
A Farmersburg man has been sentenced to 12 years in prison after pleading guilty to a rape that occurred at his parents’ residence in May 2012.
Still no information being released on Rosedale homicide
No new information was being released Monday afternoon concerning a Rosedale homicide.
Woman condemned for killing at age 15 freed from Rockville prison
INDIANAPOLIS — A woman who was sentenced to death at age 16 for taking part in the torture and murder of a 78-year-old bible studies teacher was released from an Indiana prison today after growing to middle age behind bars.
UPDATE: All lanes of I-70 now open
All lanes of Interstate 70 in Vigo County are now open — as of 4:15 p.m. — after multiple crashes shut down the eastbound lanes temporarily this afternoon.
Quinn signs into law tough fracking regulations
CHICAGO — Illinois Gov. Pat Quinn signed legislation giving the state the nation’s strictest regulations for high-volume oil and gas drilling.
BREAKING: Arrest made in Archer homicide
A Terre Haute man has been arrested and charged with felony murder and altering the scene of a death in the homicide of his wife, Kayla Herchelroath Archer.
Frye Road Overpass work to restrict lanes on I-70
VIGO COUNTY, Ind. – The Indiana Department of Transportation announces the Frye Road Overpass construction will restrict the left lane on Interstate 70 between the 13- and 14-mile marker, beginning June 17. This lane restriction will be in effect for 24 hours a day for about two weeks.
Vigo County Jail Log: June 17, 2013
The following individuals were booked into the Vigo County Jail by area law enforcement on Friday, Saturday and Sunday, based on jail records.
Fathers take time out to spend quality time with children, grandchildren
A big, circular white cloud rose up through the tall atrium as Mike Woods held his 4-year son, Nathan, Sunday at the Terre Haute Children’s Museum.
On Friday, hit the park and raise funds for skateboarders
The On-board United Initiative — O.U.I. for short — has scheduled an all-ages fundraising event Friday in honor of national Go Skateboarding Day.
STATE OF THE STATEHOUSE: Sentencing law could benefit juveniles
Monica Foster is a longtime public defender who’s been pushing uphill in the legal system for a long time. So, when she says the General Assembly is making progress protecting the rights of the disenfranchised, it’s worth stopping to listen to her.
Mastering the art of Gardening
The Wabash Valley Master Gardeners group gathered over the weekend to marvel at each other’s gardens on its annual garden tour. The event was a chance for master gardeners to showcase their labor of love, meanwhile sharing stories about their plants.
RESTAURANT INSPECTIONS: June 17, 2013
The Vigo County Health Department inspected the following food establishments May 28-31:
Lawn mower fire destroys barn
A lawn mower that caught fire was cited as the cause of a fire that destroyed a single story barn Sunday in the 2000 block of North Chamberlain Street, said Harold Osborn, assistant fire chief of the Lost Creek Township Fire Department.
Wabash Valley residents vie for spot on Wheel of Fortune
Ellen Fujawa of Zionsville wants to be on the popular syndicated Wheel of Fortune game show.
- More Local & Bistate Headlines
- Lane restrictions next week on U.S. 41 at Shelburn