BEDFORD —
The family of a slain 1976 Terre Haute South Vigo graduate breathed a collective sigh of relief Tuesday evening when the Greencastle man convicted of her brutal murder received a maximum 160-year prison sentence.
The resentencing of William A. Minnick in Lawrence Circuit Court likely assured that the man convicted of the 1981 murder of Martha Rushing Payne would not be released with “good time credit” from prison this coming October — or anytime before he turns 98.
In addition to his 60-year sentence for Payne’s murder, Judge Andrea McCord also sentenced Minnick to consecutive 50-year terms for rape and robbery, making him eligible for release in October 2061.
“Wrung out,” said Jim Payne said when asked how his testimony and Tuesday’s sentencing hearing affected him. A graduate of South Vigo himself, he had married Martha in June 1980. “But I’m relieved because we had this fear that the worst could happen. That he couldn’t get anything for rape and robbery.”
In fact, Payne said that Minnick’s statements during the hearing sounded to him almost like an apology and an admission of guilt.
“I felt that after all these years, he was almost ready to admit it,” Payne said of Minnick, who has proclaimed his innocence despite confessing to police shortly after the homicide.
Putnam County Prosecutor Timothy Bookwalter agreed.
“It sounded like he was admitting it,” Bookwalter said of Minnick’s statements to the judge.
“If a person could go back and change the past, he’d change the past,” Minnick said to Judge McCord when asked what he thought his sentence should be. “You can’t tell the victim’s family you are sorry, because the state will try to use that against you. But you are sorry.”
The judge also heard testimony from Martha Payne’s 81-year-old mother Eleanor Royer, her older sister Sharon Powell, Indiana State Police Detective Richard Rice, and retired police officer Jim Hendrich, who was a Putnam County Sheriff’s Deputy in 1981.
The hearing started almost an hour late, after Minnick became combative prior to the hearing, prompting his defense attorney to request a postponement in the hearing due to his mental health. The judge denied that request, and Minnick appeared attentive during the hearing.
Martha Payne’s family testified to the young woman’s vital lifestyle, and her mother Eleanor Royer said she discouraged her daughter from following her desire to help people by joining the Peace Corps.
“I thought it was dangerous,” Royer said. “Of course, she would still be living now probably if she had entered the Peace Corps.”
Her sister Sharon Powell said that coping with the memories of her cherished sister was like trying to live with a broken arm.
“You know you want to reach for those memories. How much do you want to reach for that when you know it’s going to be so painful,” Powell said, saying that the knowledge of what Martha endured in her torturous death clouds the good memories.
Martha Payne would be 53 now, but her life ended Oct. 26, 1981 in the Greencastle home that she and husband Jim had bought to renovate. Jim Payne asserts that Minnick stalked his wife in the days before the troubled teen entered the couple’s home to rape, stab, strangle and torture Martha.
Minnick, now 48, was only 18 at the time of the homicide. He was soon arrested and convicted by a jury of Payne’s murder while committing rape and robbery. He was given the death penalty.
But after a series of appeals, Minnick was found incompetent to be executed by the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals. His death-penalty decision was overturned in 2000, leaving Minnick with only the 60-year murder conviction. In July 2004, the Indiana Supreme Court ordered that Minnick be resentenced because his underlying sentence was no longer valid. Minnick was found incompetent to aid his legal counsel in his defense, having been diagnosed with schizophrenia while in prison. A competency hearing in March 2011 found him able to aid his counsel in the sentencing, leading up to Tuesday’s hearing.
Minnick indicated he would appeal the new sentence.
Prosecutor Bookwalter said he expects that the appeals court likely will uphold this new sentence.
State News
Related Videos
Related Photos
-
Arriving: Bill Minnick is seen walking with Lawrence County deputies to his sentencing hearing in the Lawrence County Courthouse on Tuesday in Bedford. Lisa Trigg
-
Martha Rushing Payne's senior photo — 1976 Terre Haute South Vigo High School graduate. (Submitted photo)
-
Wedding photo for Martha and Jim Payne. They got married in June 1980. (Submitted photo)
-
Memories: This family photo of Martha Rushing Payne, among others, was entered into evidence at Tuesday's hearing. (Submitted photo)
Discussion
VIDEO: William Minnick resentenced for brutal 1981 crime
- State News
-
-
Indiana’s high school grad rate continues upward
Indiana’s reported high school graduation rate continues to improve, moving from 77 percent to more than 88 percent in less than a decade, but there are still significant achievement gaps marked by race and income.
-
Schools chief Ritz on fast learning curve
For many occupants of the Indiana Statehouse, the week after the General Assembly wraps up its final frenzy of work is a quiet one. But not for Glenda Ritz.
-
SLIDESHOW: Governor Otis R. Bowen
Photos from the Indiana State Archives of the late Otis R. Bowen, who served as governor of the state as well as in the Ronald Reagan White House. The Bremen native died Saturday
-
Out of office, Lugar shuns retirement
One year ago, Indiana’s longest serving U.S. senator was rejected by Republican primary voters and forced into an unwelcome retirement from a distinguished political career that spanned 46 years. But at 81, former U.S. Sen. Richard Lugar is hardly in a resting mode.
-
Lugar wary of Syria involvement
Former U.S. Sen. Richard Lugar has been out of office since early January, but he’s still being sought after for his opinion about foreign policy matters he once helped shape.
-
Judge grants class status to lawsuit again BMV
INDIANAPOLIS — As many as 4 million Indiana drivers could become plaintiffs in a lawsuit alleging the Indiana Bureau of Motor Vehicles has overcharged for driver’s licenses since 2007.
-
Budget deal includes little funding for criminal code reform
Facing the end-of-session deadline, Indiana legislators moved forward on a bill to overhaul the state’s criminal sentencing laws but left undone the issue of where local communities will get the money to implement it.
-
Legislators closing in on final budget
In his first four months as the chief budget maker in the Indiana House, Republican Rep. Tim Brown hasn’t been surprised by the long hours, multiple demands and intense debate that goes with crafting a $30 billion spending plan.
-
New poll shows voters tepid on Pence tax plan
With just days to go before the deadline for a final budget bill, a new independent poll shows Republican Gov. Mike Pence may not have gotten much mileage for his travels around the state pitching his 10 percent tax cut plan.
-
DOC hopes ‘cold case’ cards lead to solved cases
Indiana state prison officials are using customized playing cards for a deadly serious purpose: To help unlock the mysteries of unsolved murders and persons gone missing.
-
Indiana attorney general says Congress must act on immigration reform
Amidst concerns that the Boston Marathon bombing may derail federal action on comprehensive immigration reform, Indiana Attorney General Greg Zoeller is turning up some collective heat on Congress to move ahead.
-
Disagreements stall criminal code reform bill
Negotiations over the final language in a bill that rewrites Indiana’s criminal code may come down to the last week of the legislative session.
-
Budget forecasters predict bigger drop in gaming revenues
While a gaming bill is still in play in the General Assembly, state budget forecasters are predicting the payoff to the state from legalized gambling will be even lower than they thought.
-
Legislature heads into final stretch
The Indiana General Assembly has slogged its way through hundreds of bills since convening in January but in some critical ways, the real work has just begun.
-
Criminal records bill passes Indiana Senate
Legislation that would allow some people with long-ago arrests and convictions in Indiana to wipe clean their criminal record has moved one step closer to the governor’s desk.
-
Court challenge likely for welfare drug-testing bill
Both chambers of the Indiana General Assembly have passed a bill that ties drug testing to welfare benefits, but if signed into law, the next debate may be on the question: Is it constitutional?
-
Push to roll back ban on in-state tuition for immigrants stops short
House Republicans who wanted to roll back a two-year-old ban on in-state tuition for the children of undocumented immigrants have abandoned their plan to expand a Senate bill covering a much smaller group of students.
-
House committee OKs in-state tuition for some undocumented students
The debate over in-state college tuition for the children of undocumented immigrants is headed for the Indiana House.
-
Legislators working on funding plan for criminal code rewrite
As legislation that overhauls Indiana’s criminal code moves forward, supporters of the bill are working on finding funding for local communities to implement it.
-
Republican super PAC leader backs immigration reform
As the politics of immigration reform heats up in the Statehouse and Congress, a prominent Republican is ramping up his efforts to rid the influence of what he calls anti-immigrant “extremists” in his party.
-
House considers bill to shorten school day
Legislation that would have freed the state’s high-performing schools from the mandatory 180-day school year has been amended in the House with a provision to shorten the school day instead.
-
House committee debates ban on in-state tuition for immigrant children
Two years after banning the children of undocumented immigrants from paying in-state tuition rates at the state’s public universities, Indiana legislators are debating whether to roll back that prohibition.
-
Pence says Senate GOP plan for 3 percent tax cut not enough
Indiana Gov. Mike Pence appears to be still dug in on his demand for a 10 percent income tax cut, despite a “nod” from Senate Republicans willing to give him a smaller slice of what he wants.
-
Conservative coalition supports rollback of immigrant tuition ban
Supporters of a national coalition of conservative clergy, law enforcement and business leaders are calling on Indiana lawmakers to roll back the state’s ban on in-state college tuition for the children of immigrants who came here illegally.
-
Pence’s 'ERASER' bill appears dead
Legislation pushed by Gov. Mike Pence to eliminate licensing requirements for more than a dozen occupations is apparently dead, killed by a lack of support from both Republicans and Democrats in the General Assembly.
-
Bill limiting seclusion and restraint to discipline students moves ahead
Legislation aimed at reducing the use of physical restraints and locked isolation rooms to discipline students continues to gain support in the General Assembly.
-
House committee pushes Pence to negotiate Medicaid expansion
Indiana Gov. Mike Pence has insisted he won’t expand what he calls the “broken” Medicaid health insurance program for the poor, but some state legislators are encouraging him to do so, even it’s called by another name.
-
Debate over pot penalties not over in Indiana
The politics of pot may keep Indiana lawmakers from rolling back the state’s tough marijuana laws this session, but it won’t eradicate the push for decriminalization.
-
Gun-rights lawmaker wants tougher gun penalty
One of the chief sponsors of legislation that would rewrite the Indiana criminal code wants to amend the bill to add a mandatory five-year prison sentence for using a gun to commit a felony.
-
DOC says criminal code bill will cause spike in prison numbers
A week after Gov. Mike Pence caught lawmakers by surprise with his opposition to a major criminal code reform bill, the state Department of Correction is projecting the bill will blow up the state’s prison population far beyond what the legislature’s non-partisan research agency says it will.
- More State News Headlines
-
Indiana’s high school grad rate continues upward
Looking for Love? Take the Prague Metro
Moore, Okla. City of Reunions, Tears After Storm
Oklahoma: Images of Devastation, Reunion
First Person: Baby Falcons on a New York Bridge
Crews Race to Find Survivors of Okla. Twister
Reunited Dad, Son: 'We Just Praise God'
Arias Tells Jury What She'd Do if She Gets Life
AP Photograher: 'It Was a Miracle' They Got Out
Raw: Tearful Reunion After Okla. Tornado
Raw: Aerial View of Moore Tornado Damage
Raw: Crews Search for Survivors of Okla. Tornado
Tim Cook Defends Apple's Tax Accounting
Gov. Fallin: Okla. Facing Horrific Disaster
OKC Hospital Describes Treating Tornado Wounded
Raw: Massive Funnel Clouds in Oklahoma
Former IRS Chief: Can't Say How List Happened
Raw: Widespread Destruction in Moore, Okla.
Families Begin Returning to Their Homes in Moore
Slow Pokes: Acupuncture Helps Sick Turtles
Lawyer: Feds Investigating Susan Powell Case
Kate Middleton's Dress Flies Up
VIRAL: Baby makes epic soccer goal
The Hangover Baby All Grown Up
Olivia Munn Flaunts Her Bikini Bod
Britney Spears Under Fire Once Again For Being A Bad Mom
The all-new Xbox One
RAW: Massive tornado strikes Oklahoma
Nidal Hasan paid $278K while awaiting trial
VIDEO: Teacher reunites mother and son after tornado levels elementary school in Oklahoma City
Okla. tornado survivor finds dog buried alive under rubble
Jennifer Lawrence Gets Naked and Painted Blue as X-Men's Mystique
Pickler's Dance Moves Cause A Stir
Obama to tornado survivors: The country stands beside you
Reporter Cries Over Devastation
Sneak Peek: 'Modern Family' Says Good Bye
Trailer: 'The Last Stand' Available on Blu-ray Disc, DVD, Digital Download
IWitness Look at Moore, OK Tornado
RAW: Moore, OK tornado touches down near school
Robert Pattinson Moves Out
