VINCENNES —
In a blast from the past, the Indiana high school class basketball debate raged into 2012 on Monday in a town meeting at Vincennes, 16 years after the multi-class system was approved by the Indiana High School Athletic Association.
“Raged on” might not be the right characterization for the turnout at the Lincoln High School auditorium. There were 46 people in attendance for the meeting, designed partially to re-ignite the once-hot debate regarding multi-class sports.
Fifteen people spoke in two-minute segments to IHSAA commissioner Bobby Cox and Indiana Senator Mike Delph (R-Carmel), who sponsored a bill that proposed a change from multi-class basketball back to the single-class system used until 1996.
Principals in the IHSAA membership approved the multi-class system in 1996 which sparked contentious debate at the time.
“In my humble and personal opinion, basketball is a sport unlike any other sport in Indiana. It sets us apart from other states. It’s part of our national, and in some cases, international identity of as a state. With that cultural fabric, I think we need to respect that,” Delph said during the meeting.
Of those who said their piece in the 40-minute meeting, nine spoke in favor of the multi-class system, three spoke in favor of the old single-class system and three others expressed other concerns.
Among the nine who spoke in favor of multi-class sports, seven of them were either administrators or coaches from three schools — North Knox, Barr-Reeve and Boonville High Schools.
“To go to a one-class system would equate to one class for softball, girls basketball, and potentially, football. There’s a generation of student-athletes now who are developing their own traditions. I would ask that they find their own way and their own traditions. I would ask that we keep class sports,” Boonville principal Mike Whitten said.
“There are many points of view as it concerns the Indiana state tournament. Many have come people not directly involved,” Barr-Reeve boys basketball coach Bryan Hughes said. “To those who try to minimalize the accomplishments of schools like Barr-Reeve, Loogootee or Edinburgh, I say you’re wasting your time. Those accomplishments feel great and are of tremendous value to our communities.”
There were voices in favor of returning to the single-class system. The Vincennes area was once a touchstone of the single-class/multi-class debate as Vincennes Lincoln’s dominance of its single-class sectional (67 won during the single-class years) was often used as an example to give small schools opportunity in a multi-class system.
“I’m frustrated that this part of our society in Indiana was taken away from us. I’m frustrated that the desires of small-school athletic directors overtook this statewide idea we had,” Peter Askins of Vincennes said. “Sure it’s a big deal for [Vincennes] Rivet or Loogootee to win a championship, but it’s 25 percent of a trophy. That’s all it is to me.”
Others didn't express an opinion on the single or multi-class system, but rather, touched on some of the other woes they perceived the IHSAA Tournament has.
“I think what needs to be considered is the negative vortex the tournament is in and the apathy that’s pulling it down,” said Mike Ruff of Jasper.
One speaker, Horace Foncannon of Vincennes, provided a blunt opinion on the proceedings themselves.
“Why are we having these hearings?" Foncannon exclaimed to Cox and Delph. "You know nothing’s going to change. There’s more small-school principals than large school principals. Nothing’s going to change."
Cox agreed to the town meetings — the meeting at Vincennes was the second of 11 that are planned — to open the topic for state-wide discussion. Public meetings were not conducted in 1995 and 1996 when the move to the multi-class system was proposed and implemented.
In a pamphlet distributed at the meeting, Cox said, “Our objective this evening is to allow the public an opportunity to voice their opinions about the formats used to determine state championship teams in the sport of basketball.”
One of the observers at the meeting who didn’t speak publicly was Shakamak High School athletic director and boys basketball coach Steve Brett. The veteran coach has experienced high school basketball in Indiana in nearly every meaningful way at all enrollment levels.
He played at Loogootee until 1967, just before the legendary Lions’ teams that made the single-class Final Four in 1970 and 1975. He has coached at Class A schools, including Shakamak and alma mater Loogootee, as well as Seymour, a 4A school.
“When it first came out, I was totally, absolutely against it. I’m still not totally in favor of it, but it’s been around for 14 years now and kids today don’t know any different,” Brett said.
Brett admitted that a return to the single-class format would be very difficult.
“I’ve never been in favor of putting people in classes. The American way is that we’re one class of people. In reality, that’s not true, and in basketball, that’s not true either. It would be awful tough to go back to the single-class format,” Brett said.
Brett also noted that meetings like the one held on Monday would have done a lot more good had they taken place in the mid-1990s, when the topic was an emotional one for many Hoosiers.
“They should have had meetings like this when they did it the first time. I think people might have accepted it better. But, of course, us who were into the old way, it’s hard to give it up, us old-timers. The hysteria isn’t what it used to be, but the kids today don’t know any different,” Brett said.
The third meeting of 11 takes place at 7 p.m. today at Plainfield High School. It is the only meeting scheduled in the Indianapolis metropolitan area and the only one of two within the proximity of the Wabash Valley.
High School
Class basketball debate draws 46 to Vincennes
- High School
-
-
North baseball pulls away from South in sectional opener
In high school baseball little things mean a lot, and the crack in the door doesn’t have to be open very wide.
Terre Haute North burst through that crack in the bottom of the second inning Wednesday evening at Terre Haute South, scoring seven two-out runs and going on to a surprisingly easy 12-2 victory over the host Braves. -
Blank, Mundy named McMillan Award winners
Posing side-by-side for photos following Terre Haute North High School’s Senior Awards ceremony, seniors Calvin Blank and Chanli Mundy couldn’t look more different.
-
West Vigo baseball advances with 10-0 win behind Stewart's two-hitter
West Vigo got off to a good start in Class 3A high school sectional baseball action Wednesday evening at Dick Ballinger Field.
The Vikings scored four runs in the first inning of the first sectional game and went on to defeat Brown County 10-0 in five innings with Kevin Stewart hurling a two-hitter. -
Terre Haute South tennis claims regional crown
It was a lot tougher than some thought it would be, but the Terre Haute South girls tennis team won the Greencastle regional for the second year in a row Wednesday evening at DePauw University Tennis and Track Center.
-
Big group of Wabash Valley boys head to Evansville looking for state berths
The top four finishers in each event from last week’s Terre Haute North, Evansville Central, Jasper and Princeton boys high school track and field sectionals will converge on Evansville Central today for regional competition.
-
West Vigo comes up short against 19-9 Brown County softball
West Vigo got off to a good start but Brown County finished better in Class 3A high school softball sectional semifinal action Tuesday night at Edgewood.
The Eagles bested the Vikings 7-5 and will meet South Vermillion, a 12-7 winner over Owen Valley, for the sectional championship on Thursday starting at 6 p.m.
-
Valley baseball teams have been keeping busy heading into sectionals
When high school baseball sectionals begin around the Wabash Valley today, one complaint that’s not expected to be heard from any coach is that his team has had too much time off.
-
Northview powers way past Terre Haute South in sectional semifinal
Northview unleashed power rarely seen in high school girls softball Tuesday night to eliminate Terre Haute South 8-1 in the Class 4A Sectional at Martinsville High School.
The Knights hit three home runs in an eight-run third inning to reach the championship game. -
Terre Haute North dominates field at regional
Keirra Porter took first place in two individual events and helped Terre Haute North win one of its relays as the Patriots captured the Evansville Central Regional team championship in girls high school track and field Tuesday night.
-
PREP ROUNDUP: South tennis cruises into regional final
Terre Haute South didn’t lose a game en route to blanking Seeger 5-0 in girls high school tennis Tuesday to advance to today’s championship match against Crawfordsville in the Greencastle Regional.
-
Terry enjoys strong year with Wildcats, and still enjoying suiting up to play
South Vermillion’s Tim Terry is the longest tenured coach in Wabash Valley high school baseball as his Wildcats are set to begin sectional play Thursday against Owen Valley.
But on the Yankees, a 35-and-over team in the Terre Haute Men’s Senior Baseball League, Terry is “just a youngster” if you ask Larry Roesch, his 68-year-old teammate on the Volkers Group Yankees. -
West Vigo softball holds off nemesis Edgewood in softball sectional
Ice cream was enough of a reward Monday night after the West Vigo Vikings beat eight-time defending champion Edgewood 6-2 in extra innings in the opening game of the Class 3A softball sectional at Edgewood High School. But that’s not what Vikings want.
-
PREP ROUNDUP: Shakamak's Green hits two homers in win over West Vigo
Shakamak improved to 22-3 on the season behind a complete-game effort from Brett Yeryar, and Patrick Green hit two solo home runs in a high school baseball game Monday.
-
Terre Haute North offense unable to get going in loss to Mooresville
Jack Kirchner chose to give credit Monday night to Mooresville pitcher Taylor Chitwood, not to the Greg Maddux-size strike zone she seemed to enjoy.
But if there were no excuses forthcoming from Kirchner and his Terre Haute North High School softball team, it wouldn’t have been hard to find a spectator or two to come up with extenuating circumstances about the Patriots’ 4-1 loss at the Class 4A Martinsville Sectional. -
Terre Haute North looking strong going into girls track regional
Terre Haute North might need an off night for anyone to catch them in the girls track regional at Evansville Central.
The Patriots are as well-rounded as they’ve ever been, and two relay teams are state contenders with times ranking No. 2 in Indiana among times recorded all spring.
Terre Haute South, Northview and Sullivan have athletes among the contenders in multiple events as well. -
South tennis ready for potential challenge in regional
Terre Haute South and Northview take respective records of 10-5 and 11-5 into the Greencastle Regional today.
-
Softball sectionals up for grabs
All three Vigo County high schools and Northview appear to have a realistic chance of winning sectional championships in softball this week.
-
Terre Haute South, Northview vie for tennis regional title
Terre Haute South and Northview take respective records of 10-5 and 11-5 into the Greencastle Regional today.
Coach Bill Blankenbaker’s Braves will play Seeger at 4:30 p.m., while coach Emily Goff’s Knights will take on Crawfordsville about 6 p.m. -
Vikings win in extra innings at Rockville
West Vigo scored six runs in its first two innings Saturday, then needed a ninth-inning single by Lucas Fagg to escape with a 7-6 extra-inning win in nonconference high school baseball at Rockville.
-
TH South beats Northview in Big Four makeup baseball game
Terre Haute South wrapped up a share of the MIC baseball title and finished up the Big Four Classic with an 8-1 victory over Northview in less than 24 hours on Saturday morning.
-
Olds pitches South to share of MIC baseball title
Friday night, winning the second game 5-0 and earning a share of the Metropolitan Interscholastic Conference high school baseball title.
Damon Olds was dominant on the mound for the Braves, striking out 14 and walking just one while pitching a three-hit shutout. -
South wins first half of doubleheader against Lawrence North
Host Terre Haute South kept its Metropolitan Interscholastic Conference high school baseball title hopes alive — and clinched no worse than second place in the process — by downing Lawrence North 4-1 in the first game of a doubleheader Friday night.
The second game, which started after Senior Night festivities between games, ended past the Tribune-Star deadline. -
PREP ROUNDUP: Calleja pitches West Vigo past South Vermillion
Brandon Calleja had 13 strikeouts to lead West Vigo to a 5-1 victory against South Vermillion in high school baseball Friday.
Brandon Behringer went 2 for 4 with two RBI for the Vikings, who secured second place in the Western Indiana Conference.
Kaden Lawson had double for South Vermillion (15-7), which finished 4-2 in the WIC. -
Seibert returns from injury to win three events as Braves win sectional crown
His baseball equivalent might be Rick Sutcliffe of the 1984 Chicago Cubs.
When Tyler Seibert returned to the Terre Haute South track and field lineup Thursday for sectional action at Terre Haute North, it was like the midseason trade the Cubs made for Sutcliffe that earned them a playoff spot. -
South switches up lineup to defeat North in tennis sectional
Terre Haute South coach Bill Blankenbaker said two weeks ago that he would change the Braves’ lineup after the 3-2 dual-meet loss to Terre Haute North.
The Patriots knew it was coming, but they couldn’t do anything to stop it. -
PREP ROUNDUP: North slips past Northview in eight-inning baseball game
Colton Pittman drew a bases-loaded walk to score Zach Milam with the winning run in the bottom of the eighth inning as host Terre Haute North edged Northview 8-7 in high school baseball Thursday at Jennings Field.
-
PREP ROUNDUP: North and South to face off for tennis sectional title
The winner of the Terre Haute sectional for girls high school tennis will come down to Terre Haute North and Terre Haute South.
-
Terre Haute North gets 10 event victories to claim 12th straight sectional crown
Terre Haute North won 10 events Tuesday night while winning the Indiana High School Athletic Association girls track and field section at South Putnam High School for the 12th straight year.
-
North, South to meet in first round of baseball sectional
The Indiana High School Athletic Association announced pairings for the baseball state tournament Tuesday and the draw offered up a Vigo County battle in the opening game.
-
PREP ROUNDUP: West Vigo softball clinches share of WIC title
West Vigo clinched at least a share of the Western Indiana Conference softball title with a 6-4 victory over Edgewood on Tuesday.
Jacy McClain and Bailee Waters had RBI singles in the fourth inning to break the game open for the Vikings. - More High School Headlines
-
Okla. Teens Get Video of Deadly Tornado Overhead
Raw: Aftermath of Deadly Attack in London
Britain Attack Believed Linked to Radical Islam
Man Shot While Questioned in Boston Probe
Texas Students Coach Teachers on Fitness
Raw: Scuffles in London After Hacking Death
Raw: Kevin Durant Tours Moore After $1M Pledge
Chain-Reaction School Bus Crash Injures About 50
Weiner Launches Bid to Become NYC Mayor
Johnson: Don't Blame Islam or UK Policy
School Storm Protection Spotty in Tornado Zones
Meet MJ, the Bike Riding Tabby Cat
Today in History May 23
9-year-old Tornado Victim Loved Family, Singing
Oklahoma Survivors, Heroes Survey Damage
New Forecasting Tool Eyed for Hurricane Season
Moore Native Toby Keith Tours Tornado Damage
Today in History May 22
Wash. State Man Arrested Following Ricin Scare
Raw: 80-Year-Old Climbs Mount Everest
AK-47-wielding thug may be the most bumbling crook ever
Trout's cycle a boost for Angels
Raw: New Video of Deadly Oklahoma Tornado
Kim Kardashian Flaunts Pregnant Bikini Body in Greece
NBA star pledges $1M to help tornado recovery
Shakira's Shocking Talent
Morgan Freeman falls asleep on air
GRAPHIC: Blood-Soaked Machete Killer Caught on Tape
Elin Nordegren Furious With Lindsey Vonn For Parading Kids in Public
Camera Captures Climber As He Loses Grip And Falls
Helen Mirren Meets with Dying Boy in Queen Elizabeth's Place
Crowd Chants '¡Si, Se Puede!' After Passage of Immigration Bill
DWTS Crowns a Winner
Police Ram House to End Hostage Standoff
Demi Moore a Rocks Bikini at Harry Morton's Family House
Anthony Weiner: I'm running for New York City mayor
Kate Middleton's Dress Flies Up
VIRAL: Baby makes epic soccer goal
The Hangover Baby All Grown Up
