VINCENNES —
In a blast from the past, the Indiana high school class basketball debate raged into 2012 on Monday in a town meeting at Vincennes, 16 years after the multi-class system was approved by the Indiana High School Athletic Association.
“Raged on” might not be the right characterization for the turnout at the Lincoln High School auditorium. There were 46 people in attendance for the meeting, designed partially to re-ignite the once-hot debate regarding multi-class sports.
Fifteen people spoke in two-minute segments to IHSAA commissioner Bobby Cox and Indiana Senator Mike Delph (R-Carmel), who sponsored a bill that proposed a change from multi-class basketball back to the single-class system used until 1996.
Principals in the IHSAA membership approved the multi-class system in 1996 which sparked contentious debate at the time.
“In my humble and personal opinion, basketball is a sport unlike any other sport in Indiana. It sets us apart from other states. It’s part of our national, and in some cases, international identity of as a state. With that cultural fabric, I think we need to respect that,” Delph said during the meeting.
Of those who said their piece in the 40-minute meeting, nine spoke in favor of the multi-class system, three spoke in favor of the old single-class system and three others expressed other concerns.
Among the nine who spoke in favor of multi-class sports, seven of them were either administrators or coaches from three schools — North Knox, Barr-Reeve and Boonville High Schools.
“To go to a one-class system would equate to one class for softball, girls basketball, and potentially, football. There’s a generation of student-athletes now who are developing their own traditions. I would ask that they find their own way and their own traditions. I would ask that we keep class sports,” Boonville principal Mike Whitten said.
“There are many points of view as it concerns the Indiana state tournament. Many have come people not directly involved,” Barr-Reeve boys basketball coach Bryan Hughes said. “To those who try to minimalize the accomplishments of schools like Barr-Reeve, Loogootee or Edinburgh, I say you’re wasting your time. Those accomplishments feel great and are of tremendous value to our communities.”
There were voices in favor of returning to the single-class system. The Vincennes area was once a touchstone of the single-class/multi-class debate as Vincennes Lincoln’s dominance of its single-class sectional (67 won during the single-class years) was often used as an example to give small schools opportunity in a multi-class system.
“I’m frustrated that this part of our society in Indiana was taken away from us. I’m frustrated that the desires of small-school athletic directors overtook this statewide idea we had,” Peter Askins of Vincennes said. “Sure it’s a big deal for [Vincennes] Rivet or Loogootee to win a championship, but it’s 25 percent of a trophy. That’s all it is to me.”
Others didn't express an opinion on the single or multi-class system, but rather, touched on some of the other woes they perceived the IHSAA Tournament has.
“I think what needs to be considered is the negative vortex the tournament is in and the apathy that’s pulling it down,” said Mike Ruff of Jasper.
One speaker, Horace Foncannon of Vincennes, provided a blunt opinion on the proceedings themselves.
“Why are we having these hearings?" Foncannon exclaimed to Cox and Delph. "You know nothing’s going to change. There’s more small-school principals than large school principals. Nothing’s going to change."
Cox agreed to the town meetings — the meeting at Vincennes was the second of 11 that are planned — to open the topic for state-wide discussion. Public meetings were not conducted in 1995 and 1996 when the move to the multi-class system was proposed and implemented.
In a pamphlet distributed at the meeting, Cox said, “Our objective this evening is to allow the public an opportunity to voice their opinions about the formats used to determine state championship teams in the sport of basketball.”
One of the observers at the meeting who didn’t speak publicly was Shakamak High School athletic director and boys basketball coach Steve Brett. The veteran coach has experienced high school basketball in Indiana in nearly every meaningful way at all enrollment levels.
He played at Loogootee until 1967, just before the legendary Lions’ teams that made the single-class Final Four in 1970 and 1975. He has coached at Class A schools, including Shakamak and alma mater Loogootee, as well as Seymour, a 4A school.
“When it first came out, I was totally, absolutely against it. I’m still not totally in favor of it, but it’s been around for 14 years now and kids today don’t know any different,” Brett said.
Brett admitted that a return to the single-class format would be very difficult.
“I’ve never been in favor of putting people in classes. The American way is that we’re one class of people. In reality, that’s not true, and in basketball, that’s not true either. It would be awful tough to go back to the single-class format,” Brett said.
Brett also noted that meetings like the one held on Monday would have done a lot more good had they taken place in the mid-1990s, when the topic was an emotional one for many Hoosiers.
“They should have had meetings like this when they did it the first time. I think people might have accepted it better. But, of course, us who were into the old way, it’s hard to give it up, us old-timers. The hysteria isn’t what it used to be, but the kids today don’t know any different,” Brett said.
The third meeting of 11 takes place at 7 p.m. today at Plainfield High School. It is the only meeting scheduled in the Indianapolis metropolitan area and the only one of two within the proximity of the Wabash Valley.
High School
Class basketball debate draws 46 to Vincennes
- High School
-
-
Goatee, Bertoli ran away with Spring Athlete of the Year
When honoring athletes after a season of excellence, the phrase “what might have been” doesn’t usually come up.
But in the case of Terre Haute South’s Jackson Bertoli and Terre Haute North’s TaPring Goatee – the Tribune-Star’s Athletes of the Year for spring sports – there’s an air of unfinished business despite obvious recent successes.
-
Post 346 opens tournament with two victories
Preston Tofaute got on base enough to score three runs, Cody Thornton smashed a two-run triple in the first inning and pitcher Pete Lannoo scattered four hits over a seven-inning complete game.
All of that helped Wayne Newton Post 346 down Lafayette Post 11 by a 7-2 score in the opener of the Terre Haute Inviatational tournament for American Legion baseball Thursday afternoon at Terre Haute North High School. -
North boys move up to 13th in golf state finals
Early Wednesday morning, Terre Haute North senior Ryan Baker and coach Abe Nasser headed out to the Legends of Indiana Golf Course for a range session.
Baker wasn’t happy with the 85 he shot in Tuesday’s first round of the IHSAA boys golf state finals.
“He was frustrated,” Nasser said.
Problem solved. Baker bounced back with a 2-over 74 Wednesday, helping the Patriots improve their team score by seven strokes.
The Patriots shot 304 as a team Wednesday, giving them a two-day score of 615, good for 13th place in the 15-team field. -
Big hill to climb for North golf
Terre Haute North boys golf is 21 strokes behind leaders at IHSAA boys golf tourney.
-
Top of her game
There are a lot of surprising facts about blossoming volleyball prodigy Caitlyn Newton, including that shape-shifting thing she can apparently do, but maybe one of them stands out the most. She may only be scratching the surface.
-
Camp, Howe win, then lose in state tennis tourney
Miranda Camp and Nicole Howe of Terre Haute South won their first match of high school tennis Friday at the state individual doubles finals, then won the first set against a powerful Park Tudor team before falling in three sets.
-
Terre Haute North heading back to state finals in boys golf
Terre Haute North is going back to the state finals in boys high school golf for the first time in more than 10 years. The Patriots qualified for a trip to The Legends Course next week by tying for third in the Washington Regional at Country Oaks Golf Club and advancing with the better fifth score.
-
North, South, Sullivan to compete at golf regional
Boys high school golf teams from the Wabash Valley will compete in the Washington Regional on Thursday, seeking a spot in the state finals to be played next week.
-
Terre Haute North falls 6-1 to Brownsburg in opening game of Class 4A Regional
Terre Haute North coach Shawn Turner told the Patriots to raise their heads. He wanted to see their eyes at the close of their 24-7 high school baseball season.
-
Terre Haute North girls shine on dreary day at track state finals
Led by a record setting 3,200-meter relay team and Keirra Porter’s long jump, Terre Haute North turned in its best finish ever in the 40th annual IHSAA Girls Track & Field Championships on Saturday at Indiana University in Bloomington.
-
Valley teams will have to wait until Monday for baseball regionals
Rain and the threat of more rain caused postponements of high school baseball regionals involving Terre Haute North, West Vigo and Shakamak on Saturday.
-
Rockville's season ends at Lafayette Central Catholic
Lafayette Central Catholic ended Rockville’s tourney run in high school baseball Saturday, defeating the Rox 8-0 in the first game of the LCC Class A Regional.
-
IHSAA boys state track finals: Standing alone
It hadn’t been a particularly good day for Wabash Valley track and field Friday, and it wasn’t looking like a good one for Jackson Bertoli either.
-
Terre Haute North, West Vigo return to baseball regionals
Terre Haute North’s baseball team hasn’t participated in an IHSAA regional since 2006. West Vigo’s wait hasn’t been as long, but it was 2010 when the Vikings last advanced from a sectional.
-
Patriots girls take aim at state track title
Terre Haute North’s girls have several potential state champions today at Indiana University.
-
South, North track athletes looking for big performances at state finals
Terre Haute South’s distance trio of Jackson Bertoli, Logan Hambrock and Riley Stohler appear to be the favorites to crack all-state status among Wabash Valley competitors today in the IHSAA boys track and field state finals at Indiana University.
-
Internet site keeps area prep teams on airwaves
- PREP ROUNDUP: Locals to take part in Hoosiers All-Star Game
-
South Vermillion softball can't overcome errors, Tri-West
Uncharacteristic errors led to eight unearned runs and hard-luck hitting made that impossible to overcome for South Vermillion, which fell 8-0 to Tri-West in Class 3A regional play.
-
Clay City softball comes up short against Lutheran
Clay City closed its high school softball season Tuesday night with the best record ever for the program at 21-9.
The Eels wanted to add another win, the school’s first regional title, but they came up short.
-
PREP ROUNDUP: Rockville wins baseball sectional
Rockville won its own Class A sectional in high school baseball Tuesday, defeating Covington 10-4 in the rain-delayed championship game.
-
Class 4A Terre Haute South Sectional:The wait is over
Three minutes into an interview with various media members, Terre Haute North baseball coach Shawn Turner couldn’t react fast enough to avoid a bucket of ice water being dumped over his head from behind by his giddy players. The soaking-wet Turner could shake it off with a smile, however, because his Patriots had just won the IHSAA Class 4A Terre Haute South Sectional championship with a 13-3 six-inning triumph over Plainfield on Monday evening.
-
Class 4A Terre Haute South Sectional: TH North, Plainfield win squeakers
The high school baseball teams of Terre Haute North and Plainfield proved Monday that what a batter does early in the game is not necessarily indicative of what he will do in the late innings.
-
Class 2A Linton Sectional: Eastern rains on Sullivan parade
Mother Nature put Sullivan’s quest for a high school baseball sectional championship on hold Monday night at Linton-Stockton High School. Sullivan (14-15) and Eastern Greene (16-7) will resume play in the Class 2A Sectional 47 championship game at 5 p.m. Tuesday at Linton’s Roy Herndon Field.
-
Opening Day: Terre Haute Rex host Quincy
In his first season at the helm, first-year Terre Haute Rex manager Ronnie Prettyman is going to be surrounded by men he knows and trusts.
-
Class A Shakamak Sectional: Stout pitching leads Union, Shakamak to final
Trey Bedwell and Patrick Green made sure their respective high school baseball teams would meet for the championship of the Class A Shakamak Sectional by pitching shutouts in semifinal contests Monday afternoon.
-
Class A Rockville Sectional: Covington, Rockville title game postponed
Rockville and Covington won semifinal high school baseball games Monday to advance to the championship game of the Rockville Class A Sectional. Due to rain, the championship game was postponed. A decision was expected this morning whether the game will be played today or Wednesday.
-
South Vermillion, Linton, Clay City look to stay alive in softball
There might have been as many reasons to think they wouldn’t be winning sectionals this spring as evidence to show they would, but high school softball teams from South Vermillion, Linton and Clay City will be playing one-game regionals Tuesday with the chance to keep defying the odds.
-
West Vigo back on top of Class 3A baseball sectional
West Vigo won its sectional with a 6-4 victory over South Vermillion on a rainy night at Dick Ballinger Field.
-
South runs into ‘buzzsaw’ at girls tennis semistate
Postmatch interviews don’t often begin with a coach and a reporter ready to blurt out the same word, but that was the case for Bill Blankenbaker and his interviewer Saturday morning after the Center Grove Semistate for girls high school tennis.
Unfortunately for Blankenbaker’s Terre Haute South team, that word was “buzzsaw.”
Greenwood’s Kawamoto twins made quick work of the top of the Braves’ singles lineup, so despite stellar efforts by both South doubles teams the Woodmen’s 3-2 victory didn’t seem all that close.
Greenwood moves on to Fishers, where it plays Floyd Central or Jasper on Friday in the state quarterfinals.
Also playing Friday, but at Park Tudor, will be South’s Miranda Camp and Nicole Howe, who reached the individual doubles finals for the second straight season by virtue of their 6-4, 6-2 win over the Greenwood team of Taylor Hudnall and Brittany Toney.
“It’s really exciting,” said Howe of the prospect of a second straight finals trip, “but I wish our team could’ve gone with us.”
- More High School Headlines
-
Unusual Heat Wave Bakes Alaska
Raw: Massive Protests Fill Brazilian Streets
Fans Cheer Dramatic Heat Comeback
Raw: Car Jumps Curb in NYC, Injures 8
Raw: Volcano Erupts Near Mexico City
Hunt for Ex-Teamster Boss Hoffa's Remains Ends
Tiger on Sergio: 'It's Time to Move On'
Raw: NASCAR Driver Jason Leffler Dies in Wreck
Raw: Arizona Wildfire Scorches 8 Square Miles
Hoffa Mystery Still Fascinates After 4 Decades
Car Crash in NYC's East Village Injures 8
Raw: German President Welcomes President Obama
Ohio Woman Accuses 3 of Holding Her Captive
Raw: Huge Fire Near Yosemite National Park
Raw: 1 Dead in Shooting at Mo. Apartment Complex
Obama Renews Call for Nuclear Reductions
Failed Cuba-to-Florida Swimmer Won't Try Again
3 Charged in Ohio With Enslaving Mom, Daughter
Ex-NFL Star Chad Johnson Out of Jail
Aug. Trial Set for Ohio Man in Triple Kidnapping
Men's Warehouse fires Zimmer, founder and face of company
Rihanna Hits Fan With Microphone
Exclusive: Locklear & Seymour Lock Lips
Miami Heat Wins in Overtime
Fists, chairs fly in restaurant brawl
Journalist Michael Hastings Dies in Fiery Hollywood Crash
Hairy Leg Stockings Aim to Deflect Male Attention
Inside Kim Kardashian's Premature Labor
Three Charged for Enslaving Mother and Daughter
Spurs' Popovich has no problem with Spurs' intensity
RAW: NSA Director Says 50 Plots Foiled
Paige Butcher Scorches on Hawaii Beach
Video: worst way to load cargo onto a plane
Never-before-seen footage of '08 Times Square bomber
Obama: NSA Secret Data Gathering 'Transparent'
WATCH IT: Lil Wayne tramples American flag
Mariah Carey Looks Beautiful in a Tiny Cut-Out Swimsuit
