The recession is over. The recession is not over. The recession is so close to being over that it might as well be over.
Just a few weeks ago, we were able to say the recession is over. Then the data were revised so that the latest information indicates the recession is very nearly over. Yes, Gross Domestic Product (GDP), that fickle measure of the value of goods and services produced in our country, is currently estimated to be just 0.4 percent below the pre-recession high in the fourth quarter of 2007. Indeed, just give us another $56 billion in output and we’ll be over the hump.
Yet, as we know too well, the nation’s employment is lagging. In June this year, there were 6.6 million fewer jobs than four years earlier. Indiana has 195,000 fewer jobs, a deficit of 7.5 percent compared with the national shortcoming of 5.6 percent.
What happens when the demand for labor decreases?
You’re correct. The wages of workers fall. However, how far they have fallen depends on where you live. In June 2007, the average hourly wage in the United States was $20.82. To buy the same basket of goods in June 2011, you would need 8.3 percent more, another $1.73 per hour or $22.55, just to keep pace with inflation. Fortunately, the average hourly rate this past June was $22.80, 25 cents above the inflation-adjusted wage.
Clearly, the American worker is prospering, now able to buy 25 cents more in goods and services than four years ago for each hour worked. Work a full 8-hour day, and you get $2 more in goodies when the whistle blows. It might not buy a beer in a bar, but you might get a 12 oz. bottle to take home. And you should be at home, not in a bar drinking.
How about the Hoosier worker? S/he is now earning $20.30 per hour, or $1.05 less than the inflation-adjusted hourly wage for Indiana. Our current level of pay is 4.9 percent below what we would have enjoyed if we kept pace with inflation. We find ourselves with the 8th worst pay shortage among workers in the 50 states.
These data do not matter to the true Hoosier. Remember the state motto, “Ask not what goes on here, but ask what is happening in Kentucky, Illinois, Ohio, or Michigan.” As long as our performance is better than one of those four states, we are doing just fine.
Luckily, Illinois workers are behind us; they rank 3rd in the nation in falling short of meeting the inflation-adjusted wage for June 2011. Michigan and Ohio are both doing better than Indiana. Kentucky, that spoil-sport, is among the top ten states with wages in excess of the inflation-adjusted wage.
There you have it. For all practical purposes we are out of the recession in terms of output. However, we are producing about the same output as at our peak in 2007 with far fewer workers. In 31 of the 50 states, average hourly wages remain below the inflation-adjusted hourly wage. Workers in those states, as in Indiana, are not yet able to buy with an hour’s wage what they could buy 4 years ago.
Morton Marcus is an independent economist, speaker, and writer formerly with IU’s Kelley School of Business.
Business
Fewer people are working and working for less
- Business
-
-
What do we mean ‘the recession has ended’? And, has it?
This column is not intended to confuse you, but to share the difficulty of making flat statements about a complicated matter. Be patient and, maybe, together we can make sense out of what appears to be chaos.
-
Chamber seminar on ‘Protecting Your Brand Online’
Reading online reviews and doing research is routine for many consumers before making a purchase. That means false or negative reviews can have a major impact on a business’ bottom line, often requiring swift action to minimize the damage. The Indiana Chamber of Commerce is hosting a seminar designed to help companies combat this growing issue and to help protect their overall online reputation.
-
Social Security: Father’s Day advice: The right kind of fishing
This Father’s Day, you may be inclined to spend some quality time with Dad, maybe take him out camping or fishing. But try to make sure that nobody else tries to “phish” with you or your father.
-
Newsmaker: June 16, 2013
Watermark Residential, a wholly owned Thompson Thrift subsidiary, has been named to Multifamily Executive magazine’s 2013 Top 50 list of “Builders,” placing 45th.
-
Company invests in Indiana State theater
The Indiana State University Foundation recently announced that Bison Financial Group has made a charitable gift in support of Crossroads Repertory Theater.
-
AAA plans Member Appreciation Week activities
AAA Hoosier Motor Club will conduct Member Appreciation Week festivities in celebration of AAA members June 17-22 at all branches.
-
On the move: June 16, 2013
Brittany Michaels has been appointed as the community connections coordinator for the Vigo County Public Library.
-
Secretary of State office to implement technology upgrades
Secretary of State Connie Lawson announced technology upgrades to her office’s customer services, including an online tool to allow Hoosier businesses to receive email notices when it is time to file business reports.
-
Business Cents: Interview process key to attracting and retaining skilled, talented workers
As our economy continues to grow, there are challenges with identifying a skilled and talented workforce in the Wabash Valley.
-
UAP Clinic announces new CEO
Union Associated Physicians Clinic (UAP Clinic) has announced the appointment of Mindy Smith as its chief executive officer.
-
ISU center helps prepare grads for job market
Indiana State University is launching a comprehensive skills training program to certify the skills its graduates have for potential employers.
-
Eye on the pie: Growth, compensation just as important as jobs themselves
When you come down to it, having a job isn’t enough to make it in modern America.
-
Sycamore Insurance Associates moves to familiar Ohio Street location
A ribbon cutting ceremony on May 30 marked Sycamore Insurance Associates LLC’s move “back home” to 999 Ohio St., the location of the former Sycamore Agency, Inc.
-
On the move: June 9, 2013
The Maple Center for Integrative Health announces the addition of licensed massage therapist Nancy Humphries to the clinical staff. She received her training from the Body Therapy Institute in Siler City, N.C.
-
Briefly: June 9, 2013
Scotts Place, formerly Old Gringos, staged a grand opening on Thursday in Marshall, with a Marshall Chamber of Commerce Ribbon Cutting ceremony.
-
WTHI-TV’s Mark Allen to retire
After nearly a half century of work in Indiana television, WTHI-TV’s longtime anchor, Mark Allen, will be retiring at the end of June.
-
Chamber of Commerce: The final strategic initiative: Health and Wellness
Thank you to all who participated in the Long Range Planning Community Forum. The information gathered at that event is now being drafted into a final report. Once the report has been reviewed and approved by the Terre Haute Tomorrow Steering Committee, the real work starts. Action teams to address the major issues will be developed.
-
Newsmakers: June 9, 2013
Scott’s Custom Colors recently won a contest through Enterprise which entailed a $5,000 donation to a charity important to them.
-
Social Security: A reason to smile: Online account options
Next Saturday, June 15, is Smile Power Day. Smack dab in the middle of the month — in the middle of the year, in fact — is a holiday dedicated to the power of smiling.
-
Major part of community’s image determined by the newspaper
To many Americans, Indiana is known for corn and the 500 race. These are views that are out-of-date and injurious to the state.
-
Social Security: Social Security’s most popular baby names list
Jacob and Sophia are repeat champions as America’s most popular baby names for 2012.
-
Hamilton Center part of trauma-informed community
Hamilton Center, Inc. is one of 37 behavioral health organizations across the United States that have been chosen to participate in the National Council for Community Behavioral Healthcare’s 2013 Trauma-informed Behavioral Healthcare Learning Community launched in April.
-
Business Cents: Do you have a disaster plan in place for your business?
Due to recent events, I began to ponder just how many companies have a disaster plan in the case of a natural disaster, fire, etc.
-
Newsmakers: June 2, 2013
The Indianapolis Business Journal recently named Watermark Residential as one of the 25 “Largest Indianapolis-Area Commercial Real Estate Developers.” Watermark was 4th on the list.
-
Chamber seeks Community of Year nominations
The Indiana Chamber of Commerce is now accepting nominations for the 2013 Community of the Year Award.
-
On the move: June 2, 2013
Deena Dodd, director of the Terre Haute-based Indiana Statewide Rural Health Network, was elected to the board of directors of the National Cooperative of Health Networks Association at the association’s annual meeting in New Orleans.
-
Indiana farmers make rapid progress planting corn
WEST LAFAYETTE, Ind. — Indiana farmers who had worried that wet spring weather would prevent them from planting some of their corn fields have made rapid progress getting the state's top crop in the ground.
-
Indiana State Fair to host job fair May 30
The Great Indiana State Fair is hoping to fill more than 500 hourly positions during a job fair from 3 to 7 p.m. May 30. Most of the jobs are temporary positions that cover the duration of the fair, which runs Aug. 2-18.
-
NEWSMAKER: May 26, 2013
Distributors Terminal Corp. has earned 940 out of 1,000 points on AIB International’s annual food safety audit.
-
SOCIAL SECURITY: Social Security honors all who serve
Every day of the year, Americans across the nation remember friends and family members who have served and sacrificed for their country.
- More Business Headlines
-
What do we mean ‘the recession has ended’? And, has it?
Historic Ruling Set in Affirmative Action Case
Tiger on Sergio: 'It's Time to Move On'
Raw: NASCAR Driver Jason Leffler Dies in Wreck
Raw: India Floods Wash Away Apartment Building
Raw: Marines Land Osprey on Japanese Ship
Need an Organ? A Lab-Grown One May Work One Day
Family Tweets Say Kim Kardashian Gives Birth
Ex-NFL Star Chad Johnson Out of Jail
Tebow Thanks Patriots for Opportunity
Solar Plane Reaches East Coast
Failed Cuba-to-Florida Swimmer Won't Try Again
Raw: Prince Philip Leaves Hospital After Surgery
Prosecutors Push for Smartphone "Kill Switch"
Colorado Springs Wildfire 65% Contained
Raw: Obama, Daughters Visit Trinity College
FBI Searching Mich. Field in Jimmy Hoffa Case
Raw: FBI Meets Plane After Poison Threat
Raw: Australian Begins Cuba to Florida Swim
Google Launches Internet-beaming Balloons
Obama Welcomes WNBA Champions to White House
Caught on Tape: Davie Teacher Accused of Beating Autistic Child
See Lindsay Lohan in Rehab
"Stay Classy" Campaign Aims to Curb Binge Drinking
Lil Wayne's New Music Video Has Some People Outraged
Gaga Ditches Her Crazy Couture
Sesame Street Tackling Tough Topic Parents in Jail
Miss Utah Fumbles Interview Question
Deranged man claims Newark-bound flight was poisoned
Cameron Diaz and Kate Upton Show Off Their Amazing Bikini Bodies
NBA FINALS: Spurs Win Game 5, Lead Series
Exclusive Clip: Jodi Arias: 'Dirty Little Secret'
Amphibious bus filled with tourists sinks
Best Bikini Abs
Mix-Up at Daytime Emmy Awards
Kim K. Is a New Mommy!
Sarah Silverman Roasts Mel Brooks at AFI Tribute
Moderate Cleric Wins Iranian Election
Obama on Fatherhood: 'Best Job I've Got'
