TERRE HAUTE — We often hear that President Obama’s economic stimulus package will create lots of “green jobs.” But we should be skeptical whenever people in government claim to be creating jobs, green or otherwise.
Proponents of Mr. Obama’s plan say his green jobs will include, among other things, making solar panels, insulating homes and building windmills.
Here’s a quote from the Web page of the Environmental Defense Fund praising the job-creating benefits of using windmills to make electricity.
“A typical wind turbine is made of more than 8,000 parts. Think of the skilled workers needed to make these parts, weld them together, deliver them to site and construct the facility.” Just a small wind project site uses “at least 6,500 tons of steel, 609 tons [of] composite fiberglass and 12,470 tons of concrete.” And this is “good news,” according to the Web site.
In other words, the more labor and material-intensive something is, the better. Does anyone else feel there might be something wrong with this sort of thinking?
I believe there are two serious problems with government efforts to create green jobs. First, and most important, we seem to be confusing job creation with wealth creation.
The government could create a lot of jobs in the same way it is creating green jobs by simply outlawing or badly hampering existing jobs. This is pretty much what we’re seeing with the “cap and trade” legislation now before Congress. This legislation would make carbon-based energy sources, such as coal, much more expensive and limited. As a result, alternative forms of energy — that are not economically viable now — suddenly appear viable. Presto! Green jobs!
In a similar way, the government could create a lot of green jobs in bicycle manufacturing by imposing a massive tax on gasoline and automobiles or simply outlawing cars completely. Suddenly, demand for bikes would rise and production would follow suit. Viola! Lots of new bike manufacturing jobs would be “created.”
Unfortunately, creating wealth is not as easy as creating jobs. The creation of wealth requires production. And living standards only rise when we are able to produce more goods with the same or fewer inputs of labor, land, time and capital. But much of the green job agenda involves simply replacing existing forms of production with other — more costly — forms of production. It’s very difficult to see how this will make us generally better off.
The second big problem with the crusade for green jobs is net job growth. In short, green jobs will come at the cost of other jobs. Andrew P. Morriss, a law professor at the University of Illinois, recently explained this aspect of the problem in a paper for the Independent Institute.
“Spending billions would certainly produce green jobs, but it would also eliminate jobs in areas that lose government favor,” Morriss wrote. “Green jobs advocates rarely count the job losses their programs will cause. For example, shifting electricity production from coal to wind means that many coal miners, truck drivers, utility workers and other employees will lose their jobs as energy prices soar.”
In another recent study, Gabriel Calzada, an economist at King Juan Carlos University in Madrid, Spain, estimated that each green job created by the Spanish government’s subsidies for wind and solar energy since 2000 cost 2.2 jobs in other industries. And that doesn’t count jobs lost in Spain due to companies leaving the country because of much higher energy prices.
The government cannot really create jobs. It can effectively outlaw alternative jobs designed to achieve the same thing. But simply banning one form of production to stimulate an alternative form of production seems like a strange way to make people better off.
Government also can subsidize certain types of jobs, but this doesn’t really create jobs, either. If the subsidy comes from taxes, taxpayers simply have less money to spend in other areas. This costs as many jobs as it creates. If the subsidy comes from government borrowing, private investment will decline, and again, jobs are lost. And if the subsidy comes from creating new money, the purchasing power of existing money will simply decline.
A large number of economic studies have found that as societies and countries grow wealthier, their environments become cleaner and safer. A competitive market economy, where private property rights are respected, is probably the best route to a cleaner environment. The green revolution could be doing long-term harm to the environment it is meant to protect.
Arthur Foulkes writes a column on business and economics. The Tribune-Star reporter is a Terre Haute native and longtime resident. He can be reached at (812) 231-4232 or arthur.foulkes@tribstar.com.
Business
Related Photos
-
Joseph C. Garza
Discussion
ARTHUR FOULKES: Golden promises: Beware of the ‘green job’ boondoggle
- Business
-
-
Business Cents: Customers and companies: Sugar goes further than vinegar
Working with companies for more than decade I am still shocked to learn how not only companies react to customers but also how rude customers can be to companies.
-
SOCIAL SECURITY: Can’t work because of disability? Let us help
Disability is something most people don’t like to think about. But if you’re not able to work because you have a disabling condition that is expected to last at least one year or result in death, then it’s a subject you may not be able to avoid.
-
Naysayers should treat good news as good news
I like to complain as much as anybody else. In truth, I may do more than my share of finding fault and wagging a finger in warning. Nonetheless, I’m tired of commentators (including many economists) who find nothing good and only the darkest clouds for the past few months.
-
All mothers appreciate extra help
Think of all the times and ways that your mom has helped you over the years — when you were a child, and after you became an adult. With Mother’s Day upon us, now is a good time to pay mom back with a little Extra Help — with her Medicare prescription drug costs.
-
Upcoming meetings
The Terre Haute Chamber of Commerce is hosting a health care reform seminar for businesses from 2 to 3:30 p.m. on Tuesday at Old National Insurance at 925 Wabash Ave., suite 200.
-
Indiana ranked best place to do business in Midwest
Indiana was ranked as the best place to do business in the Midwest and the fifth best nationwide in a survey of more than 500 chief executives by Chief Executive magazine.
-
First Farmers rated among top 100 community banks
First Farmers Bank & Trust of Converse was named one of the 100 top-performing community banks for 2012 by SNL Financial.
-
Newsmakers: May 12, 2013
Employer Support of the Guard and Reserve has recognized John Thompson, president of Thompson Thrift Construction, and Paul Thrift, president of Thompson Thrift Development, as “Patriotic Employers.”
-
On the Move: May 12, 2013
Stacey Joseph, a realtor in Terre Haute, has earned the Certified Residential Specialist designation by the Council of Residential Specialists, the largest not-for-profit affiliate of the National Association of Realtors.
-
Chamber lauds four with Business Recognition Awards
Congratulations to our Business Recognition Awards winners! Our Awards Luncheon at the Meadows Banquet and Conference Center was a great event to wrap up Business Recognition Week, sponsored by Union Hospital. At the Luncheon we recognized four local businesses as the 2012 Business Recognition Award winners:
-
ISU students provide detailed grocery analysis
As the National Cooperative Grocers Association makes business decisions in the coming years, the organization likely will take into account an analysis of some of its competitors – about 4,000 of them.
-
Construction firm holding grand opening in Marshall on Friday
Construction, H&H LLC is holding a grand opening and Marshall Chamber of Commerce ribbon cutting ceremony on Friday at 812 N. Second St. in Marshall, Ill.
-
AP Source: Subaru to expand Indiana plant
Subaru plans to expand its Indiana factory and add workers to build the Impreza small car in 2016, a person briefed on the matter says.
-
Transit proposals can prove to be game changers
After baseball, my favorite TV watching is the government channel. Here I can see the local government in action or local government inaction.
-
On the Move: May 5, 2013
Melissa Schollaert, RDH, HHP, has been added as a counselor of holistic health and nutrition at The Maple Center for Integrative Health.
-
ISU set to offer financial planning program in 2014
When Indiana State University junior Jennifer Groth began scheduling classes last semester, she planned them out by thinking of an academic program the university does not yet offer. Groth will be one of the inaugural students in the financial planning program that ISU will begin to offer in spring 2014.
-
Newsmaker: May 5, 2013
Gov. Mike Pence announced the appointment of Jessica Robertson to commissioner of the Indiana Department of Administration, a role she will begin on Wednesday.
-
U.S. Postal Service opens village office in Worthington
The U.S. Postal Service officially opened the 40th Village Post Office in the Greater Indiana District on Monday in Worthington.
-
How consistent is your business?
There are six areas in which consistency is critical in the majority of companies. Too often, business owners feel as they are “chasing down” rather than “leading it along.” If you can get a high level of consistency with your standards and practices, then your company will benefit.
-
Good time to try Spanish online service
Cinco de Mayo is May 5 — a time to celebrate Mexican heritage and pride. Why not join the celebration by visiting Social Security’s Spanish website, where you’ll find a number of useful services and a wealth of information in Spanish.
-
First Financial’s net income up 3 percent
First Financial Corp. has announced results for its quarter that ended March 31. The Corp.’s net income increased 3.4 percent to $7.7 million, compared to $7.4 million for the same period of 2012.
-
Curtain goes up on new theater owner
The Indiana Theatre in downtown Terre Haute is under new ownership with a new purpose.
-
Indiana Theatre SOLD!
The Indiana Theatre at 683 Ohio St. is sold.
Rob Lundstrom, who owns the Copper Bar and Louise’s, took possession of the historic downtown theatre on April 25. -
Higher education completion rates questioned
Spring is really here. Baseball is being played, the Cubs are already tragic and Faye of the Forest reappeared on the back deck. She was parked on the railing as I sat down to write this column.
-
Vectren Corp. awards $2.3 million in grants
Vectren Corp. has announced that it awarded more than $2.3 million in 2012 through the Vectren Foundation and corporate contributions.
-
Hard work, good attitude produces success
Like clockwork, Indiana State University graduate Joe Evelo regularly provides monthly updates to the first client he signed up when he started his financial investment career more than 35 years ago.
-
On the move: April 28, 2013
Old National Bank has promoted Howard Mills to vice president, mortgage loan originator.
-
Newsmakers: April 28, 2013
Lenise Kohlway of Spencer was presented with the WorkOne Achievement Award last week for overcoming several employment barriers and pursuing a better life for herself.
-
Ivy Tech offers free business counseling
The Ivy Tech Business and Entrepreneurial Services Center and the Terre Haute chapter of SCORE are offering free, confidential business counseling and low-cost high-impact training workshops to aspiring entrepreneurs and existing small business owners.
-
Social Security: Try this word puzzle challenge
In 1938 — only a couple of years after Social Security was signed into law — a depression-era, unemployed architect named Alfred Mosher Butts studied the front page of The New York Times to figure out how often each of the 26 letters was used. The result was a game he called Criss Cross Words, renamed 10 years later as Scrabble. In honor of Scrabble’s 75th anniversary, we’d like to challenge you to a word puzzle.
- More Business Headlines
-
Business Cents: Customers and companies: Sugar goes further than vinegar
Probe Begins After Conn. Commuter Trains Crash
Coffee Run Leads to Hatchet Hitchhiker Arrest
NTSB Begins Investigation Into Conn. Train Crash
Conn. Commuter Trains Collide; 60 Go to Hospital
Lotto Fever Sweeps the Country
Fmr. IRS Head Insists No Politics in Targeting
NM Mom Chases Down Child Abductor
Raw: Gun Scare Mars Cannes Film Festival
Raw: Suicide Bomber Kills 2 Americans, 13 Others
China, Others Want What's Under the Arctic Ice
CDC: Fecal Bacteria Common in Swimming Pools
Raw: Texas Gov. Flies Over Tornado Damage
$1 Million in Jewels Stolen at Cannes Film Fest
Raw: Obama Sits Down With Elementary Kids
Raw: 6 Die in Russian Ship Fire
One Million Evacuated As Cyclone Hits Bangladesh
Raw: Driver Ejected From Truck, Over Bridge
Raw: Germany Protestors Picket Barbie House
Wash. State Releases Draft Rules for Legal Pot
Dying Man's Blinks Lead to Murder Conviction
Twiggy, the Water Skiing Squirrel
Sailor Surprises His Mom At Her CU Denver Graduation Ceremony
Official: ‘Amazing’ No One Was Killed In CT Train Crash
Coffee Stop Leads To Arrest Of YouTube Sensation Wanted For Murder
Bearded Dragon Reunited With Owner
Marine Reunited with Warzone Companion
Raw: Crash Sends Car Into Fla. Pool
Beyonce Is Pregnant!
SF baseball player overpaid $500,000 RETURNS money -- and team says KEEP IT
Dad returns from Afghanistan, surprises family during Rays' first pitch
See Jennifer Lopez's New $10m Hamptons Mansion
Woman tricked into taking abortion pill
Emma Watson Goes Pantless
IRS scandal: Republicans seek to tie Obama to agency's woes
Play of the Day: Flipping to Safety
Pregnant Kim Kardashian Squeezes Her Swollen Feet Into Stilettos
Top Videos of the Week: Angry Taco Bell Guy, Glacier Moves on House, Dog Hates Baths
Cindy Crawford Stuns At Cannes
