TERRE HAUTE — Is private property evil? Are people who support the sanctity of private property selfish and greedy?
These are not just academic questions. They are as practical as living, surviving and prospering.
For many people, private property is another term for selfishness. They equate the concept with a child clutching a toy and saying “Mine!” Or else they have horrifying visions of a neighbor allowing junked cars to pile up in his yard without limit. For them, the defense of private property is often the defense of antisocial behavior.
But a deep cultural and legal respect for private property rights is really a matter of life and death.
Many writers have pointed out that Haiti lacks a legal system that protects private property rights. The Heritage Foundation, which ranks the world’s countries according to economic freedom, has consistently ranked Haiti among the world’s worst regarding respect for private property rights.
“Property is not secure in Haiti,” stated the Index of Economic Freedom in 2005, which gave Haiti its lowest ranking in that category. In 2010, the Index ranked Haiti’s property rights protection superior only to Burma, North Korea and Zimbabwe.
In his 2000 book “The Mystery of Capital,” economist Hernando de Soto wrote that 68 percent of urban Haitians and 97 percent of rural Haitians live on property with no clear legal title. More recently, noting the connection between a lack of property rights and the recent terrible destruction and death in Haiti, Ball State University economist T. Norman van Cott wrote:
“Tell me, if you were building a house for which you do not have legal title, how interested would you be to use your resources to build a more durable structure? Not very, I’m sure. Certainly less interested compared to if you had clear title to the structure. After all, you’re unsure about whether someone can come along and take away ‘your’ house, and you’re unsure about your ability to sell the house in the sure. The resulting shabby construction won’t cause earthquakes, but it’ll make earthquake-related damages more extensive. Even fatal.”
But isn’t all this just an excuse to defend selfishness? Isn’t it better to share everything we have with everyone? While some characterize a strong defense of private property rights as greedy and even “un-Christian,” I believe there are some pretty ancient and even sacred defenses of private property rights. For example, the commandments “Thou shalt not steal” and “Thou shalt not covet thy neighbor’s house” or anything else that belongs to him seem to me to imply an important respect for private property rights.
People certainly should not be discouraged from sharing what they earn. But such sharing should be voluntary. If not voluntary, it seems to me it’s not really the result of a moral decision to share at all. And demanding that other people be forced to share strikes me as perhaps an excellent way to appear superior and enlightened but not very useful otherwise.
Business
ARTHUR FOULKES: Respect for private property is a matter of life and death
- Business
-
-
Projected Learning: Indiana State class teams with Delta Faucet for educational efforts
Indiana State University senior Candace Greubel scoured newsletter articles before her class forwarded its project to its eager audience, Delta Faucet Company employees.
-
Eight join Scott College of Business advisory board
Eight graduates from the past decade have recently joined the Scott College of Business’ Young Professionals Board at Indiana State University.
-
NEWSMAKERS: Feb. 12, 2012
* Edward Motley
* John Wilkinson
* Clabber Girl Corp.
-
BUSINESS CENTS: Is your company ready to become a franchise?
In the past few articles, we have discussed small business tax issues.
-
Mayor of Clinton to speak at Chamber luncheon
Clinton Mayor Jack Gilfoy will be the guest speaker at the February Luncheon Meeting of the Greater Clinton Chamber of Commerce.
-
SOCIAL SECURITY: A Valentine tip from Social Security
Valentine’s Day is just around the corner, making this a popular time of year for proclamations of love.
-
Small businesses invited to enter ‘Push’ contest
The sixth annual Staples National Small Business Survey found that seven out of 10 small business owners are optimistic about the future.
-
MORTON MARCUS: Examining the vitality of the economy in local communities
Euturn Wright, the noted economic development specialist, was in Indianapolis for the Super Bowl extravaganza.
-
ON THE MOVE: Feb. 12, 2012
Big Red Liquors Inc., a leading wine, beer, and spirits merchant since 1972 with 25 retail locations throughout southern Indiana, has hired Don Rix, vice president for Marsh Supermarkets LLC with 32 years of experience in the grocery industry, as its new president.
-
Mike’s Carwash washes its 100,000,000th vehicle
Mike’s Carwash has recorded a significant milestone, washing its 100 millionth vehicle.
-
Look for random acts of kindness at mall
Honey Creek Mall in Terre Haute will again celebrate National Random Acts of Kindness Week, Feb. 13-19.
-
Estate planning, wills topic of Lunch with a Lawyer program
Senior Education Ministries Inc. has scheduled Lunch with a Lawyer from 11:30 a.m. to 1 p.m. Feb. 20 at the Wabash Senior Activity Center at 300 S. Fifth St. in Terre Haute.
-
Leslie leaving Terre Haute Chamber
The Terre Haute Chamber of Commerce today notified members that Rachel Leslie, Chamber executive vice president, has accepted a position as director of advancement operations for St. Mary-of-the-Woods College.
-
Toyota to increase Highlander output in Indiana
Toyota will increase production of the Highlander mid-size SUV in late 2013 at the company’s Princeton, Indiana plant. Hybrid and export versions will be included. The project is expected to create about 400 new jobs at Toyota Motor Manufacturing Indiana Inc.
-
AT&T expands mobile broadband network
AT&T has expanded its mobile broadband network in several southwest Indiana communities, extending access for advanced mobile services, devices and feature-rich audio and video content to customers in the area.
-
ON THE MOVE: Feb. 5, 2012
• Debbie Dillow
• Vani Manyam
• Shabaz Gill
-
Nominate someone for HR Professional of the Year
Nominations are currently being sought for the 2012 Ogletree Deakins/HR Dimensions Human Resources Professional of the Year.
-
Time Warner offers new levels of Internet service
Time Warner Cable is expanding the next generation of Internet service to customers across the Midwest using DOCSIS 3 equipment and its advanced fiber network.
-
NEWSMAKERS: Feb. 5, 2012
Irving Haber at 1818 N. Third St. in Terre Haute announces that he is the first physician in the Wabash Valley to offer on-site digital imaging with the new Sonosite Sonogram machine.
-
First Financial Corp. reports 2011 results
First Financial Corporation announced results for the year and the quarter ended Dec. 31.
-
Terre Haute Chevrolet to incorporate new GM image elements
Terre Haute Chevrolet, a division of the Romain Automotive Group of Evansville, has announced a new look coming to the dealership in 2012.
-
SOCIAL SECURITY: Social Security FAQ on disability
Question: I applied for disability benefits three months ago and still haven’t received an answer. How long does it take to get a decision?
-
MORTON MARCUS: State government increasingly decides how we live in our cities
The ongoing trend in state-local government relations in Indiana is increasing paternalism.
-
Innovative Staff Solutions offers job openings
Innovative Staff Solutions has more than 180 positions open and available right now.
-
Free career advancement workshop scheduled
University of Illinois Extension is hosting a free career advancement workshop from 5:30 to 7 p.m. Feb. 23 in Marshall.
-
Verizon Wireless invests $159 million in Indiana
Verizon Wireless has invested $159 million in 2011 to enhance its network in Indiana, which includes the expansion of 4G LTE to 23 Hoosier cities, 10 major universities and four professional sporting venues.
-
Rose-Hulman Winter Career Fair experiences 37 percent gain in company attendance
The good times have returned for college job seekers in such technical fields as engineering and computer science.
-
Gordon Chiropractic celebrates grand opening of new location
The Terre Haute Chamber of Commerce in partnership with Gordon Chiropractic Family Health and Wellness celebrated the grand opening of its new location on Feb. 4.
-
Magnolia gives in on rezoning
A potential $20-million investment in Terre Haute’s east side has been blocked by public opposition.
-
Magnolia drops retirement complex plans for Ohio Boulevard
The company that had been hoping to build a new senior living complex along Ohio Boulevard has canceled its plans.
- More Business Headlines
-
Projected Learning: Indiana State class teams with Delta Faucet for educational efforts








