TERRE HAUTE — A Vigo County man received an eight-year prison sentence after admitting that he shot his wife in the head last year just days after she had moved out of their home.
Harvey E. Hayhurst Jr., 54, will serve three years of that sentence in the Indiana Department of Correction, and five years on formal probation.
Judge Michael Lewis announced Hayhurst’s penalty for the March 27, 2009, shooting of his estranged wife Paula inside the couple’s garage at the conclusion of a sentencing hearing Thursday afternoon that included about two hours of testimony in support of Hayhurst.
“It’s not me affecting the lives of those involved, it’s his actions,” Lewis said after hearing pleas for leniency from family and friends who said the judge’s sentencing decision would affect a lot of lives.
Lewis called the case “a typical domestic violence case where the victim doesn’t want him to go to prison.”
The judge said he has struggled with the sentencing decision for the past month, ever since the original attempted murder charge was reduced via plea agreement to a charge of criminal confinement. The plea agreement allowed the sentencing to be argued before the judge with the penalty left up to Lewis.
“What bothers me most is that six shots came out of this gun and she was hit three times,” Lewis said, “and this was an attempted murder case that was pled down to one count of criminal confinement.”
Hayhurst had faced a class-B felony sentencing range of 6 to 20 years, with 10 years being the advisory sentence. While Lewis recognized no aggravating circumstances for a sentence longer than 10 years, he noted the mitigating circumstances of Hayhurst’s lack of a criminal record, the unlikelihood of a recurrence and consideration of the victim’s wishes.
An outburst of crying and yelling came from the audience gallery following the judge’s decision, and shouts of support followed Hayhurst out of the courtroom as he was escorted by sheriff’s deputies to the Vigo County Jail to begin serving his sentence.
Lewis said that after Hayhurst has served one year in prison, he will consider a sentence modification.
Hayhurst had originally been charged with attempted murder, a class-A felony, and aggravated battery, a class-B felony, in the case. But those charges were amended in February after Prosecutor Terry Modesitt noted that the victim in the case has recanted her original statements about what happened in the incident.
Chief Deputy Prosecutor Rob Roberts argued Thursday that many of the letters to the court supporting Hayhurst were written as if Paula was to blame because she had left her husband of 34 years only a few days before the incident.
Even Paula’s mother testified that her daughter shared some of the blame for the incident.
“So in your understanding of this,” Roberts asked Barbara Cooprider, “what has your daughter done to share the blame, for being partially to blame for being shot at six times and being hit multiple times?”
Cooprider responded quietly, “She wanted her space because there might have been someone else in her life.”
When defense attorney Jessie Cook clarified the woman’s response by asking if Cooprider was excusing Harvey Hayhurst’s actions, Paula’s mother replied, “Oh no, I’m not saying that.”
Harvey Hayhurst’s mother, Helen Hayhurst, testified that having her son sent to prison would be a hardship for her since he takes care of her finances, home maintenance and other duties for his widowed mother. Hayhurst’s son and daughter also testified that he helps them with child care and provides a home for his grown daughter, Crystal, and has adopted her son as his own.
Crystal Hayhurst and others also testified that in the days before the incident, Hayhurst had been taking medication that noticeably changed his mood. Crystal and her brother David both testified they were worried that their father was suicidal.
And Crystal said that when she saw the police cars outside the family home on the day of the shooting, she thought they were there because her father had committed suicide. She said she did not think he would shoot her mother.
At the end of testimony, Roberts asked the judge to sentence Hayhurst to 16 years in prison.
Defense attorneys Cook and James Boswell asked the judge for a suspended sentence with probation, and possibly home detention along with counseling.
Lisa Trigg can be reached at (812) 231-4254 or lisa.trigg@tribstar.com.
Top Story 3
Related Photos
-
Harvey Hayhurst File
Discussion
Hayhurst gets 8 years for shooting wife in head
Shooting of estranged spouse took place at southern Vigo home
- Top Story 3
-
-
PHOTOS: Wabash Valley Storm Damage
Photos from storm damage from around the Wabash Valley taken on May 26, 2011.
-
Plaza honors National Road’s influence on TH’s development
More than 100 students from Lost Creek Elementary School lined Seventh Street on a chilly Tuesday afternoon to participate in a formal dedication of the National Road Plaza, which serves as a south gateway for Indiana State University.
-
NEW: Former ISU standout, Indiana Basketball Hall of Famer Steve Hollenbeck dies at 64
Former Indiana State men’s basketball and baseball player Steve Hollenbeck died on Friday in Edinburgh. He was 64.
-
Oil struck in Eastern Vigo County
CountryMark officials are gushing over “a significant oil find” at a well site in eastern Vigo County.
-
Tanoos: School year will be extended
As of today, the Vigo County School Corp. has canceled five days of school this year because of bad weather conditions.
-
Wabash Valley hospitals use disaster plans to meet needs
The week’s crippling winter storms prompted both Union and Terre Haute Regional hospitals to activate disaster plans Tuesday, ensuring that quality medical care for patients continues uninterrupted.
-
Wabash Valley United Way gives peek at how it’s agencies help people
From family courts to basketball, United Way volunteers learned Thursday how their dollars help Valley residents cope with tough times.
-
Storm slams Vigo again; leaves 3K without power
A second powerful thunderstorm in two days left thousands of Vigo County residents without power Tuesday evening.
-
They know she can dance: 'So You Think You Can Dance' contestant has relatives in TH
Many Terre Haute residents will be glued to their TVs Wednesday and Thursday nights cheering on a dancer with strong ties to the Wabash Valley.
-
Walks hurt Rex in 4-3 loss to West Virginia
The Terre Haute Rex were their own worst enemy in the opening game of a doubleheader vs. the West Virginia Miners at Bob Warn Field on a hot, steamy — and eventually stormy — Sunday afternoon.
-
Level-headed North softball ready to play for state title
Being overlooked and underappreciated is a formula that hasn’t bothered the Patriots one bit so far this season. Considering the Patriots are 8-1 against ranked opponents, in fact, maybe it’s a blessing.
-
Rex slip in extras
Late Night at Bob Warn Field continued an unexpected run on Wednesday. Unfortunately for the Terre Haute Rex, their third extra-inning home game did not send the 861 fans home happy. On Tuesday, the Rex were able to overcome early struggles to win in the 11th inning. On Wednesday, the Rex spotted Hannibal a five-run lead, but rallied to force extra innings again. This time, Hannibal put two runs across in the 10th and the Rex had no response as Terre Haute lost 8-6.
-
Purchasing alcohol? You'll soon need a photo ID no matter what your age is
Just days before many celebrate the Fourth of July holiday, Hoosiers heading to grocery stores, convenience marts or liquor stores to purchase alcohol will need a photo ID under a new state mandatory
carding law. -
Created in Terre Haute, history of iconic Coca-Cola bottle clouded
The world knows Coca-Cola by its bottle. The contour container of “The Real Thing” is unmistakable, the most famous product package in history. People even can recognize it by touch in the dark.
-
Record-setting Special Olympics gets under way
Those rumblings through your floorboards weren’t earthquake tremors Friday night, rather the vibration of a record-busting Special Olympics program inside Hulman Center’s arena.
-
Maggie's Garden: Students honor former classmate
Packets of seeds to plant in honor of Margaret Elaine Vicory went home with all students and adults at Ouabache Elementary School on Thursday.
-
UAP Clinic, ISU enter into agreement on student health services
UAP Clinic has begun providing student health services at Indiana State University, officials say.
The two parties have a temporary agreement for the summer while they iron out final contract details, said Teresa Exline, ISU special assistant to the president for internal relations. -
North softball advances to semistate with 2-1 win over East Central
Asked how she felt pitching with one out and the bases loaded and her team leading East Central by one measly run in the top of the seventh inning, Terre Haute North’s Bethany Sullivan laughed before answering. Rest assured, however, the senior right-hander didn’t find that situation amusing Tuesday night during the Class 4A regional championship game in front of an overflow crowd at the Patriots’ softball diamond.
-
4 in a row: South claims fourth straight sectional title with 2-1 win over North
Sometimes baseball has a way of making plans irrelevant.
Host Terre Haute North was able to save the pitcher it wanted for the championship game of its Class 4A sectional on Monday, finessing its way through a nervous 11-6 win over Plainfield in one semifinal game, while Terre Haute South used ace A.J. Reed to pull off an 11-1 win over Northview earlier in the day.
And in the championship game, North’s Bryan Nacke pitched well — just not quite as well as unheralded Josh Dove and Brent Mulvihill of South, which won its fourth straight high school baseball sectional championship by a 2-1 score. -
Pushin' for 4: Castroneves seeks to become fourth driver to take four checkered flags
One of the biggest questions awaiting an answer from the 94th running of the Indianapolis 500 Sunday is “Can he do it?” Helio Castroneves is sitting in the catbird seat in his quest to become the fourth four-time winner. The pole-sitter could join A.J. Foyt, Al Unser and Rick Mears in a unique club at the Indianapolis Motor Speedway. Mears was the last driver to earn four wins, the last in 1991. Ironically, Mears works very closely with Castroneves during races.
-
Riley fifth-grader receives annual Cameron Langenfeld Character Award
Three years after the death of Riley student Cameron Langenfeld, the annual award given in his name still touches students as they reach the age at which he died.
-
MARK BENNETT: Legacy of Mordecai Brown holds special place for Terre Haute
Guys with a lifetime ERA of 2.06 don’t pump your gas anymore. Actually, most Americans fill their own tanks nowadays. But even if old-school filling stations still existed, the last man you’d expect to tap on your window and ask “Fill ’er up?” would be a Hall of Famer with two World Series rings for the Chicago Cubs.
-
Many 12 Points business owners seeking amendment to secondhand dealer ordinance
Many business owners in Terre Haute’s 12 Points business district are hoping for a change in the city’s new secondhand merchants ordinance.
-
Clark County development officials work to keep businesses moving forward
Clark County, Ill., business and economic development leaders are keeping a positive attitude despite the county’s high unemployment rate.
-
Honey Creek holds annual writers fair
Speaking to a gymnasium filled with Vigo County middle school students, Michael Shelden, a successful writer and longtime educator, followed the advice of Mark Twain who said public speakers should keep their presentations short.
-
Terre Haute attorneys competing to raise food, donations for charities
Terre Haute attorneys are going to see who can set the bar the highest in a competition designed to help hungry families.
-
Wyatt Jones, 8, collecting toys to send to children in Haiti
A Vigo County third-grader will soon be making a big difference in the lives of hundreds of needy children in Haiti.
-
High schoolers lend hand in rebuilding Deborah’s House
Volunteering youth took a once-condemned property by storm Saturday morning, assisting a local not-for-profit shelter the homeless.
“We’re hoping to have an open house in June,” Muriel Ryan said outside the property known as Deborah’s House at 2808 S. 11 1⁄2 St. -
Community gardeners break ground
Temperatures drizzled about the 40s Saturday afternoon as dozens of volunteers readied their garden plots for cool weather vegetables.
-
Hayhurst gets 8 years for shooting wife in head
A Vigo County man received an eight-year prison sentence after admitting that he shot his wife in the head last year just days after she had moved out of their home.
- More Top Story 3 Headlines
-
Raw Video: Toddler Trapped in Washing Machine
Raw Video: Fire on Nuke-powered Sub in Maine
NYPD: Person Implicated in Etan Patz Death
Astrologers Predict Outcome of Presidential Race
Gulf Fishermen Reel From Seafood Troubles
Illegal Burn Suspected in Nevada Fire
Obama: 'We've Got More Work to Do'
FAMU Bandmates: Victim Volunteered to Be Hazed
1 Dead After Crop-Dusters Collide in Midair
Castro's Daughter Takes on U.S.-Cuban Relations
Romney: "I'd Like Every Parent to Have a Choice"
Raw Video: Tornado Appears During Wedding
Raw Video: Bride Who Faked Cancer Released
Clinton Touts Rights Advances, Assails Assad
Search Intensifies for Missing Louisiana Woman
NYC Protests: the Revolution Will Be Scripted
Raw Video: School Bus Hits House
Stuntman Makes Skydive Without Parachute in UK
Raw Video: Passed Out Man Robbed
Inquiry Hears Wider Secret Service Misbehavior
Fight erupts in Ukrainian parliament over language bill.
Racy ad encourages safe sex for senior citizens
New Video of The Dark Knight Rises Released by Warner Brothers
Coach dismissed after going to prom with student
Jennifer Lopez's Rock Hard Abs
Plane Passenger Records Engine Hatch Blowing Off
What Katy Perry Thinks Makes Her Hot
Toddlers Mistake Laundry Detergent TidePods for Candy, Get Poisoned
Anderson Kicks Guest Off Show
Lolo Jones Admits Trouble Keeping Boyfriends
Behind 'Breaking Bad's' Big Bang
Big Bang Theory Star Comes Out
Laundromat video: It was the babysitter and her friend
"The Choking Game" - Deadly Trend for Youth
Sanchez Eager to Start Her Career after 'Idol'
K.Stew's Topless Confession at Cannes
American Idol Crowns a Champ
