INDIANAPOLIS — It was a dream day for Jimmie Johnson, but a nightmare for NASCAR, Goodyear and the Indianapolis Motor Speedway.
Johnson won the Allstate 400 at the Brickyard on Sunday, his second career Brickyard win, but it was a race mutilated by problems caused by excessive tire wear.
The race was littered with nine NASCAR-enforced competition yellow flags, as well as several tire failures early in the race, including violent tire disintegration on the cars of Juan Pablo Montoya and Matt Kenseth.
The race took 3 hours, 28 minutes, 26 seconds to finish. The average speed was 115.148 with 52 laps run under caution.
Most drivers said the tires had no more than 10 laps of green-flag running before they began to deteriorate.
“The last two laps of each run were not fun. I was hanging on and praying that the right rear didn’t blow out. There were a couple of runs where I could really feel it vibrate,” driver A.J. Allemendinger said.
Runner-up Carl Edwards admitted that the tire wear meant there were very few instances during the race where he ran full bore. He also admitted that the uncertainty over tires was disconcerting.
“In practice I was making sure my belts were tight and I knew where the SAFER barriers were,” Edwards said.
The cause of the tire failures vexed NASCAR and Goodyear, the series’ tire manufacturer. NASCAR has had trouble with tire wear since the Indianapolis Motor Speedway’s surface underwent diamond-grinding in 2004. The conventional wisdom was that the track surface would “rubber in” after the cars turned several laps. That’s what happened during the last three Brickyards, which ran without major tire problems.
However, NASCAR’s Car Of Tomorrow, used at Indianapolis for the first time, creates more wear on the tires than the previous car due to less downforce. Combined with the abrasive surface, it was a recipe for disaster.
“Obviously, the tread wear didn’t improve as we thought it would over the course of the afternoon. We don’t have the answer is to why that happened,” Goodyear director of race tire sales Greg Stucker said.
NASCAR anticipated problems before the race, bringing in 200 sets of tires intended for use at Pocono next week. Pocono is the track that most closely resembles Indianapolis when it comes to tire wear. NASCAR allotted each team 10 sets of “Indianapolis” tires before the race, hoping it would not need to revert to the Pocono tires. It was the first time since Dover’s 1994 race that Goodyear brought tires not intended for the track they were designed for to a different venue. The Pocono tires were never used, but most teams used up nearly all tires allocated for Indianapolis.
The first caution occurred on lap 4 as Michael Waltrip got loose entering turn 2 and was hit by Paul Menard. The second came on lap 14, just before NASCAR’s first mandated competition caution, when Kurt Busch spun coming out of turn 1 and collected Kevin Harvick.
NASCAR elected to have another competition yellow at lap 32, but tire trouble came to Dale Earnhardt Jr. on lap 25. Earnhardt Jr. led 11 laps after he had pitted during the Waltrip-Menard accident, so he had 20 laps on his tires at the time his tire went down.
NASCAR adjusted its competition yellow flag plan, pushing it back to lap 30, but not before Juan Pablo Montoya’s tire disintegrated on the front left side on lap 29 in turn 2. Montoya’s incident brought out its own yellow flag, which NASCAR counted as its second competition yellow.
NASCAR scheduled another competition yellow for lap 47. There were no incidents until lap 46 when Matt Kenseth’s right rear tire exploded on the backstretch, taking much of his right rear quarter-panel with it, leaving shredded tire tread and debris littered on the backstretch. During the same lap, Carl Edwards also appeared to have a less severe tire problem.
After Kenseth’s violent tire failure, there was major concern on the part of the NASCAR brass and teams.
“[The track] never really did take rubber, so I got really mad in the middle because they were letting us run until the tires were blowing up. I was like, ‘You can’t put us in this situation,’” Jamie McMurray said.
Competition yellows were flown on laps 64, 81, 97, 121, 138 and lap 150. Most drivers expressed relief that NASCAR accelerated the amount of competition cautions in the second half of the race, even if it gave the fans few green-flag laps to get excited about.
“As soon as we got the cautions are when I needed it. I could feel it, I was about to wreck if we didn’t have the [competition] caution,” Denny Hamlin said.
Johnson led 58 of the first 120 laps before Hamlin took a chance with a two-tire stop during the competition yellow on lap 121 to lead 26 laps late in the race.
After the last competition caution, Johnson took two cautions and made up several spots to take the lead on the last restart. He was joined by Carl Edwards in a duel for the race win. Edwards threatened Johnson on the restart, but couldn’t get past him.
“I ran like hell, that’s all I could do. I was on two tires and didn’t have the grip I would have liked, but I held him off,” Johnson said. “I’m so stoked. It’s been a tough year, we’ve had our butts handed to us a few times, it’s nice to get back with a win.”
NASCAR vice president of competition Robin Pemberton regretted the way the race turned out, but thought fans would understand.
“If they’re good fans, I’m sure they understand that things like this happen,” Pemberton said. “If you’re a good fan and you don’t get what you want, it’s OK to be disappointed. We’ll learn from this experience this weekend and do better when we come back.”
Auto Racing
Johnson wins, fans lose in Brickyard tire debacle
- Auto Racing
-
-
TRACKSIDE: Valley racing showed best, worst of times in 2011
A look back on the 2011 Wabash Valley auto racing season reveals the best and worst of times the sport has to offer.
-
Action Track to play host to 4 USAC events
U.S. Auto Club officials have released preliminary schedules for next season and four events are listed to be run at The Action Track.
-
ISU's Troxell, Crossroads Dragway in running for NHRA awards
Indiana State University student Derick Troxell and the Crossroads Dragway are both in the running for annual National Hot Rod Association awards.
-
Memorial service for Wheldon attracts thousands
Thousands came to honor deceased IndyCar driver Dan Wheldon during a memorial service at Conseco Fieldhouse on Sunday.
-
Indy remembers Wheldon
Dan Wheldon’s biggest fans wanted one more chance to thank their favorite driver.
One by one, they turned Indianapolis Motor Speedway’s main gate into a memorial for the two-time Indianapolis 500 winner, who was killed Sunday in a fiery crash at Las Vegas.
-
Wheldon fans leave tributes at Indianapolis track
Dozens of fans have left flowers, candles and notes at the Indianapolis Motor Speedway gates in memory of two-time Indy 500 champion Dan Wheldon.
-
Indy 500 winner Wheldon dies after massive wreck
Race car drivers always know the worst can happen whenever they get behind the wheel.
-
UPDATE: Indy 500 winner Dan Wheldon dies after massive crash in Vegas
Indianapolis 500 winner Dan Wheldon died Sunday at Las Vegas Motor Speedway after his car became ensnarled in a fiery 15-car pileup, flew over another vehicle and landed in a catch fence just outside turn 2.
-
It was a frigid ending to oval dirt track season
The oval dirt track part of the 2011 Wabash Valley racing season came to a highly successful and climactic end over the weekend at Lincoln Park Speedway.
-
Windom’s impressive streak evokes lofty comparisons
In the storied history of the Terre Haute Action Track no name is more synonymous with winning and dominance than the late Jim Hurtubise.
-
Windom drives away from field at Action Track
Chris Windom led all 30 laps to capture the Jim Hurtubise Classic presented by First Financial Bank for USAC National Sprints at the Terre Haute Action Track on Saturday.
-
USAC cars return to Action Track today
The United States Auto Club sprint cars return to the Terre Haute Action Track tonight for the Jim Hurtubise Classic presented by First Financial Bank.
-
Points titles are on the line at Wabash Valley race tracks
They have become as much a part of the motorsports scene as the traditional green and checkered flags.
-
Stock cars: ‘backbones’ of short tracks
It was a familiar scene played out every Saturday night throughout the summer at hundreds of short tracks scattered across the country.
-
Menard pulls off the upset
Thirteen different drivers held the lead for at least one lap in Sunday’s Brickyard 400 at Indianapolis Motor Speedway, and Paul Menard led 21 of them — including 11 of the last 12 and the last four — to take the checkered flag.
-
Family: Menard’s team won IRL title
Although it took 35 years, the name Menard finally made it to victory circle at the Indianapolis Motor Speedway on Sunday.
-
Sprint Summer Showdown begins at Indianapolis
The Sprint Summer Showdown begins today at Indianapolis Motor Speedway. The Brickyard 400 for NASCAR Sprint Cup drivers is the first of five races in the new event that will culminate with the AdvoCare 500 in Atlanta.
-
Johnson knocked off pole by upstart Ragan at Brickyard
The 18th Brickyard 400 will be run today at Indianapolis Motor Speedway.
-
Billboard aims to curb race fans’ hot dog cravings
A new billboard is warning Brickyard 400 fans that eating hot dogs can be dangerous to their health.
-
Hinchliffe looking forward to IndyCar's Canadian stops
James Hinchcliffe is looking forward to the next two IZOD IndyCar Series events to be run in his native Canada. First up is Sunday’s Honda Indy Toronto to be run on the streets of Toronto. Versus will carry the action live at 2 p.m. EDT.
-
Safety rules at track
A race delayed for more than two hours by overnight rain was eventually forced to be postponed by extreme heat and deteriorating track conditions as the vagaries of Mother Nature found another way to plague the Terre Haute Action Track on Sunday.
-
Sumar Classic hits track Sunday
Jason McCord remembers how he used to watch racing, playing catch with his father on the infield during lulls in the action on the track.
-
TRACKSIDE: Coons should be favorite for Sunday
When the U.S. Auto Club Silver Crown contingent motors into the Wabash Valley Fairgrounds this weekend for the SUMAR Classic it would appear that Jerry Coons Jr. would be the odds-on favorite to win Sunday’s 100-lap main event.
After all, the veteran driver has all the credentials to make him a winner. -
TRACKSIDE: Decision to stick with USAC pays off
When the 2011 USAC Indiana Sprint Weeks schedule was announced back in January, there were many who expressed their share of disappointment that Lincoln Park Speedway had once again been snubbed for one of the coveted series dates.
-
Stunning victory
After one of the craziest finishes in racing history, Dan Wheldon emerged as winner of the Indianapolis 500 on Sunday at the Indianapolis Motor Speedway.
Just when it looked like rookie J.R. Hildebrand was one corner away from giving Panther Racing its first Indy 500 victory, he got up into the marbles in the fourth turn, bouncing the right side of the car into the wall. -
Field still split over double-file restarts
For the first time ever at the Indianapolis 500, the IZOD IndyCar Series began using double-file restarts during the race.
-
Centennial Indianapolis 500 fill have deep meeting to today's winner
In the words of Al Unser Jr. as he stood in the winners circle in 1992, “You just don’t know what Indy means.”
-
USAC Tony Hulman Classic tonight
The 41st running of The Tony Hulman Classic for United States Auto Club cars is set for tonight at The Action Track.
-
TRACKSIDE: Auto racing in May in Indiana runs on history and tradition
Possibly nowhere in the sports world does history and tradition play such a key role in an event’s success and future as that found in auto racing.
-
MARCO, DANICA MAKE THE CUT
Every year on Bump Day at the Indianapolis Motor Speedway, the question is “Who will make it?”
The question this year was who wasn’t going to make it in the centennial running of the Indianapolis 500. When it was all over, Marco Andretti and Danica Patrick were in. Teammates Mike Conway and Ryan Hunter-Reay were out. - More Auto Racing Headlines
-
TRACKSIDE: Valley racing showed best, worst of times in 2011
Raw Video: Greek Rioting Ahead of Austerity Vote
Coroner: Houston Autopsy Results Weeks Away
Greece Passes New Austerity Deal Amid Rioting
Pop Music Superstar Whitney Houston Dies at 48
Raw Video: Child Rescued After Kosovo Avalanche
Whitney Houston's Church Mourns Her Passing
Reaction to Houston's Death at Clive Davis Party
Raw Video: Whitney Houston's Last Performance
Severe Cold Wreaks Havoc in China
Police: Houston Found Dead in Her Hotel Room
Fuel Removal Under Way on Capsized Italian Ship
Fans 'Speechless' Over Houston's Death
Snow Strands Italian Towns
79 Turtles Seized at Shanghai Airport
Video of M.I.A's Obscene Halftime Gesture
Raw Video: Italy's Mount Etna Bursts Into Life
'Rumor Has It' Adele's Rolling in the Grammys
Today in History for Tuesday, February 12th
Recording Superstar Whitney Houston Dead at 48
Stocks Fall Sharply As Greek Deal Is Held Up
Adele's revealing "60 Minutes" interview
Exclusive Video: Bobbi Kristina Leaving Hospital
Lusetich: AT&T Recap
Raw Video: Aurora Borealis As Seen From Space
2012 Grammys: Rihanna
2.12: Pebble Beach Pro-Am -- Phil Mickelson
2012 Grammys: Taylor Swift
Exclusive Video - Whitney's Bodybag
FUEL TV: Punk Payback Gym tips
Whitney's Final Days - EXCLUSIVE
Romney Tops Santorum in CPAC Straw Poll
First glimpse of Blue Ivy Carter
Angry Dad Shoots Teens Laptop
Peek inside Barbie's closet
Absolute Lin-sanity
Madonna's Daughter Shaves Head
5 Killed in Wrong-way Crash on I-10 in La.
